I disagree. It should stay water nymph with water cost and
ability.
With the introduction of the pendula ( 8) ), it is now possible to generate other nymphs with only using a water mark.
However, compared to nymph tears 6
, it costs 8
+ 4
in 2 turns for the first pillar transformation. As it is very weak (1 or 2 HP) and potentially very annoying, it is CCed very quickly.
As no other creature generator is that weak (3|7 for a firefly queen and 3|8 for a pharaon) and cost that much (4
+pillar), it should be IMO made more resistant (0|5 for earth nymph and 1|7 for the fire nymph). I would recommend 1|5 with a lower cost: 7
with the ability changing from 4
to 2
when upped.