[Old] Level 1 - Crucible - Gravity Card Ideas - 24 Cards

[wizelsnarf]

Should I just withdraw my converge | coalesce card now that chimera exists?

[miggui]

I have picked my 4 favorites:
Glutonnous Priest is a weaker, balanced, offensive option to black hole.
Power Shield is a lot overpowered (think "chimera", or even a dragon) but I like the idea if you put a cap to it.
Ribdule is very interesting, mainly because I get REALLY pissed off when someone destroys one of my permanents. Can't stop wondering if earthquake/quicksand would make it get +6/+3 though...
Acceleration/Overdrive is an interesting slow-building killer machine. Would give something to do for Voodoo Doll and Armagio... and Gargoile too.

Graviton Spellcaller/Spellbender is a nice concept, but with only 4/6 lifes he'd die REAL quick against a poison deck. I'd rather make it a spell than a creature. Cast the spell on Armagio and you're safe
Focused Gravity looks too cheap for me. I like the concept, but I like more the ones I've picked
Singularity/Event Horizon doesn't seem very useful to me...
Red Planet/Sun I just found flat out boring

[EvaRia]

I would like to make a minor change to Acceleration | Overdrive.
Nothing big, just changing "Active Ability" -> "Activated Ability".
Is this okay or will it get disqualified or something?

[ratcharmer]

I would like to make a minor change to Acceleration | Overdrive.
Nothing big, just changing "Active Ability" -> "Activated Ability".
Is this okay or will it get disqualified or something?

A simple change in wording shouldn't hurt anything.

Generally in crucible you can change your cards as you see fit. If a change is major enough the curator might reset the vote count to 0 (since it's no longer the same card people voted for), but other than that edits are pretty common at this level, sometimes even necessary.

Just make sure the table matches the new card text, I always mess that up.

[Kael Hate]

Should I just withdraw my converge | coalesce card now that chimera exists?

If you want it can be. In most cases it might be better to leave it then it can go to the archive if people no long see use in voting for it.

I would like to make a minor change to Acceleration | Overdrive.
Nothing big, just changing "Active Ability" -> "Activated Ability".
Is this okay or will it get disqualified or something?

As Said by Ratcharmer, you can tweak card ideas at any time. If the Change is something more than a minor adjustment (ie Cost or stat values) then it may appear like a different idea, and if that is the case the Curator will move it to the bottom of the list with 0 votes as it is different enough to what people voted for. In most cases people tweaked the card becasue it wasn't liked so the loss of votes is often a non-issue.

[Kuroaitou]

CURATOR COMMENT

- As there are now 26 cards in this section to vote for, the number of VOTES here has been raised to 5 votes per person. You may need to remove your vote and then vote again to use your second vote.

- Note that the cards marked with the * were added after the vote started an are immune from elimination this voting round.

[EvaRia]

You know, I've been wondering...
You say the cards with * are immune to elimination, but do any ever get eliminated?

[PhantomFox]

Once the number of cards hits the cap, yes.

[Kuroaitou]

You know, I've been wondering...
You say the cards with * are immune to elimination, but do any ever get eliminated?

Once the number of cards hits the cap, yes.

Technically, there is no cap. However, there is always a minimum amount of cards to allow for a 'standardized' amount of 4 votes per person - or 18 candidates total. When the number of cards go well over 18, the cards with the lowest votes (usually ones with 0 or 1, but sometimes a bit higher) and the oldest cards (the ones at the top of the poll) are usually cut and sent to the Crucible Archive for posterity, to bring the card limit back to around 18 (generally a little bit more than that is okay).

In other words, cards do get eliminated; it's just that we try not to remove too many at a time unless it's apparent that the card idea is lacking is some aspect that no one likes it. 

Some cards are also removed if the authors want them to be removed from the Crucible, although that's very rare...

[dramore]

minor tweek to the wording in Graviton Spellbender.   Adjusted the words "effect" and "effect" in the top part of the card to "affect" and "affect" only for grammer. no change to the idea.

Technically, there is no cap. However, there is always a minimum amount of cards to allow for a 'standardized' amount of 4 votes per person - or 18 candidates total. When the number of cards go well over 18, the cards with the lowest votes (usually ones with 0 or 1, but sometimes a bit higher) and the oldest cards (the ones at the top of the poll) are usually cut and sent to the Crucible Archive for posterity, to bring the card limit back to around 18 (generally a little bit more than that is okay).

In other words, cards do get eliminated; it's just that we try not to remove too many at a time unless it's apparent that the card idea is lacking is some aspect that no one likes it. 

Some cards are also removed if the authors want them to be removed from the Crucible, although that's very rare...

 

thats good to know as I was wondering.

[Kael Hate]

CURATOR COMMENT
For being voted from Crucible to the Forge
Congratulations to:  

Acceleration | Overdrive  
(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,10924.0.html)

CURATOR COMMENT
Apologies given for unqualifying for the Forge.
The following cards will be moved to archive for posterity.
 

Tiger Mount | Tiger Mount
(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,5694.0.html)

Trojan Pony | Trojan Horse
(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,5474.0.html)

Assemblage | Factorius
(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,6648.0.html)

[Kuroaitou]

CURATOR COMMENT
For being voted from Crucible to the Forge
Congratulations to:

Ribdule | Elite Ribdule
(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,8484.0.html)

CURATOR COMMENT
Apologies given for unqualifying for the Forge.
The following cards will be moved to archive for posterity.

Dying Star | Dying Star
(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,7350.0.html)

Graviton Hurler | Graviton Flinger
(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,7974.0.html)