War - Standings

[Amilir]

We never got told that any of our actions were against the rules, or we would of course have remedied such immediately.  Where did you get warned to use the member roles topic anyway?  I can't find it on your forum.

[Zeru]

Because I was under the impression that they were informing me of their member order in case I did not see their changes to the member roles thread. Is that not correct?

Of course you are correct. Each time I modified the "Team Order" thread, I contacted ddevans to avoid mistakes.

Now for Kael. Team Order can be changed freely any time during the war. Member Roles cannot. However, there is no indication in the rules that a certain member HAS to start his thread. As ScaredGirl said, member roles are to even out and formalize the managing job and that we can "organize like we want".

This is why I didn't see a need to make a team order changelog of any sorts. However, I can recreate it from memory for you, if you see a need to have one.

[Kael Hate]

We never got told that any of our actions were against the rules, or we would of course have remedied such immediately.  Where did you get warned to use the member roles topic anyway?  I can't find it on your forum.

It was mostly carried out in Chat and PMs.
But was resolved here http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,14572.36.html
and here http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,14728.msg204867#msg204867

Now for Kael. Team Order can be changed freely any time during the war. Member Roles cannot. However, there is no indication in the rules that a certain member HAS to start his thread. As ScaredGirl said, member roles are to even out and formalize the managing job and that we can "organize like we want".

This is why I didn't see a need to make a team order changelog of any sorts. However, I can recreate it from memory for you, if you see a need to have one.

Lol, I don't need you to do anything, in fact my detailng of player order would have been quite similar to yours detailing the change of order by PM if we had done so.

It was just the fact of us being told we would be penalised for not following a rule explicitly and then you getting away without having to do so.


If you look here http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,14512.0.html it tells you what you have to have done and what we were berated about in the first few weeks, but it seems your team (and maybe others but what need is there to scruitineer non-winners) just did what you felt like.

Your board is secret, and so it should be, so the only people who could have questioned your area are warmasters and SG. It puzzles me why we were targeted with the threat of penalty and yet you were not.




I have been disheartened by this war. I don't think I'd like to play it again until some of the imbalances have been smoothed and made fairer.

To Whomever runs next war, when something is declared it needs to held the same for everyone. Impartiality is key.

[Zeru]

but it seems your team just did what you felt like.

Actually, my team did everything perfectly until SnoWeb left for vacation. Then Nyma look over the salvagers role, but she also left. So in the very last round I was the salvager. Other than that, everything is fine.