War #6 - Suggestions and Feedback

[Spielkind]

3. Strategist
Strategists may remove up to six cards from their deck before each duel. Each duel must have a legal deck, and their full deck must also be legal. Vault penalties are not incurred for mid-battle deck errors, provided the full deck is legal and the match finished.

That's still not a good idea, more powerful than General for sure. For example, swapping in or out Dim Shields is insanely strong, forbidden mark change now means... only Aether guy can do it, yay. Or Entropy Strategist switching between Speedbow and DiscEQ.

Spoiler for Hidden:

blaa

why general has to be the most powerful battle role? i find it a good idea to make roles from "members" more battle-like, so its more fun for all!

[deuce22]

why general has to be the most powerful battle role? i find it a good idea to make roles from "members" more battle-like, so its more fun for all!

probably because they are the Masters and the strongest role should play in the final battle. A strategist vs. strategist final battle just sounds ridiculous. And that type of final battle will come down to a game-to-game mindgatefest.

[Spielkind]

why general has to be the most powerful battle role? i find it a good idea to make roles from "members" more battle-like, so its more fun for all!

probably because they are the Masters and the strongest role should play in the final battle. A strategist vs. strategist final battle just sounds ridiculous. And that type of final battle will come down to a game-to-game mindgatefest.

but general vs general stays the last battle?! you never will win wars without strategie... and the best strategie wins war! why not giving those role a more important one? general still is the head of the team!
its only a battle thing... the command is still by the general! perhaps im too roleplayer for this, but i see no probs with giving another role more battle-synergie than general! and if it is so... give general 3 more ups ^^

[Acsabi44]

why general has to be the most powerful battle role? i find it a good idea to make roles from "members" more battle-like, so its more fun for all!

probably because they are the Masters and the strongest role should play in the final battle. A strategist vs. strategist final battle just sounds ridiculous. And that type of final battle will come down to a game-to-game mindgatefest.

but general vs general stays the last battle?! you never will win wars without strategie... and the best strategie wins war! why not giving those role a more important one? general still is the head of the team!
its only a battle thing... the command is still by the general! perhaps im too roleplayer for this, but i see no probs with giving another role more battle-synergie than general! and if it is so... give general 3 more ups ^^

Okay who would you rather watch to fight:
some unnamed decepticon vs Ratchet or something,
or
Optimus vs Megatron?

It is natural that the showdown is between the two leaders, who are also the strongest.

[Absol]

What's a General's biggest advantage? (6-ups IIRC)
If General must have the biggest showdown, then every role must have less than 6 upgrades' worth of skill.

[Spielkind]

why general has to be the most powerful battle role? i find it a good idea to make roles from "members" more battle-like, so its more fun for all!

probably because they are the Masters and the strongest role should play in the final battle. A strategist vs. strategist final battle just sounds ridiculous. And that type of final battle will come down to a game-to-game mindgatefest.

but general vs general stays the last battle?! you never will win wars without strategie... and the best strategie wins war! why not giving those role a more important one? general still is the head of the team!
its only a battle thing... the command is still by the general! perhaps im too roleplayer for this, but i see no probs with giving another role more battle-synergie than general! and if it is so... give general 3 more ups ^^

Okay who would you rather watch to fight:
some unnamed decepticon vs Ratchet or something,
or
Optimus vs Megatron?

It is natural that the showdown is between the two leaders, who are also the strongest.

Gandalf vs. Saruman... no generals, but best fight! and gandalf as legolas are more stronger than aragorn... but he is the general, no other?! you dont need to be the strongest, but smart and command!

[deuce22]

I guess late in war I will change my role to strategist and make some newb general. Happy?

[RavingRabbid]

why general has to be the most powerful battle role? i find it a good idea to make roles from "members" more battle-like, so its more fun for all!

probably because they are the Masters and the strongest role should play in the final battle. A strategist vs. strategist final battle just sounds ridiculous. And that type of final battle will come down to a game-to-game mindgatefest.

but general vs general stays the last battle?! you never will win wars without strategie... and the best strategie wins war! why not giving those role a more important one? general still is the head of the team!
its only a battle thing... the command is still by the general! perhaps im too roleplayer for this, but i see no probs with giving another role more battle-synergie than general! and if it is so... give general 3 more ups ^^

Okay who would you rather watch to fight:
some unnamed decepticon vs Ratchet or something,
or
Optimus vs Megatron?

It is natural that the showdown is between the two leaders, who are also the strongest.

Gandalf vs. Saruman... no generals, but best fight! and gandalf as legolas are more stronger than aragorn... but he is the general, no other?! you dont need to be the strongest, but smart and command!

Saruman was a general, actually.
And secretly, so was Gandalf.

[Captain Scibra]

Something small, but I suggest that the "Non-upgraded cards" be "Non-upgraded Non-rares"  Just because they are listed elsewhere on the sheet, and it will be mixed in that somne people will include rare counts, some will not.

[ddevans96]

Why 16 days for applications?

[bogtro]

Why 16 days for applications?

Probably because the time period coincides with several major holidays.

[Helston]

Why 16 days for applications?

Probably because the time period coincides with several major holidays.

This.