Monolith/Obelisk series

[ralouf]

Lol this night I got the same idea : switch atk/def for the entropy ^^
The twin monolith is very nice but so good for 1 quanta I think

[The_Mormegil]

The aether monolith seems a bit too strong... and implements a nice mechanic. I'm torn. :-/

[Rutarete]

this is my idea.

That picture could work with my fake pillar idea... 

[OldTrees]

Fire Monolith is now in the Fire crucible.

[ralouf]

GO VOTE !!

[Rutarete]

For  monolith, have all airborne creatures not attack? or reverse wind and have them attack the enemy?
For  monolith, what do you think about my Energy idea?
here's the link: http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,20675.0.html

[OldTrees]

For  monolith, have all airborne creatures not attack? or reverse wind and have them attack the enemy?
For  monolith, what do you think about my Energy idea?
here's the link: http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,20675.0.html

I think blocking all airborne might be too situational. (It also requires foreknowledge of the opponent's deck to be worthwhile.)
However your Energy idea is interesting. I personally would categorize a protection like that as Light not Life but I like the idea. Updated in the OP.

The OP is updated.
4 cards to vote on:
  Fire Monolith (3 votes vs 6)
  Blue Obelisk (4 votes vs 9)
  Black Obelisk (3 votes vs 13)
  Golden Obelisk (3 votes vs 5)
I need your support!

3 new cards in design theory for later
  Light Monolith
  Time Monolith
  White Obelisk

[Rutarete]

Here are some more ideas (modified from my -Ergy series)

For monolith: kill a creature of a type already on the field (from Allergy)
For : Target creature gets the most recent buff (played?) (from Synergy)
For : No more of target creature may come into play for 3 turns.  (Unmodified from Parergy)

[OldTrees]

Here are some more ideas (modified from my -Ergy series)

For monolith: kill a creature of a type already on the field (from Allergy)
For : Target creature gets the most recent buff (played?) (from Synergy)
For : No more of target creature may come into play for 3 turns.  (Unmodified from Parergy)

Allergy (too powerful and violates a taboo.)
Synergy (it is a duplication of a spell that is worth more than it. Possible but unlikely. What do others think and what would count as buffs?)
Parergy (wow solid anti fractal or any non 4+ types of creature deck. Too powerful for an obelisk)

[Rutarete]

Here are some more ideas (modified from my -Ergy series)

1. For monolith: kill a creature of a type already on the field (from Allergy)
2. For : Target creature gets the most recent buff (played?) (from Synergy)
3. For : No more of target creature may come into play for 3 turns.  (Unmodified from Parergy)

Allergy (too powerful and violates a taboo.)
Synergy (it is a duplication of a spell that is worth more than it. Possible but unlikely. What do others think and what would count as buffs?)
Parergy (wow solid anti fractal or any non 4+ types of creature deck. Too powerful for an obelisk)

ok, how about for
3. tone it down to 1 turn - it can be useful for putting a short stall on sacrab/firefly/mitosis.
2. Make it that Each copy of target creature gets the most recent buff (this is now getting closer to my Evil Eye card)
1. Nevermind

[OldTrees]

Here are some more ideas (modified from my -Ergy series)

2. For : Target creature gets the most recent buff (played?) (from Synergy)
3. For : No more of target creature may come into play for 3 turns.  (Unmodified from Parergy)

Synergy (it is a duplication of a spell that is worth more than it. Possible but unlikely. What do others think and what would count as buffs?)
Parergy (wow solid anti fractal or any non 4+ types of creature deck. Too powerful for an obelisk)

ok, how about for
2. Make it that Each copy of target creature gets the most recent buff (this is now getting closer to my Evil Eye card)
3. tone it down to 1 turn - it can be useful for putting a short stall on sacrab/firefly/mitosis.

2:I said the effect might be too powerful and you buff it?
What do others think of the original "Target creature gets the most recent buff" idea?
What would count as buffs?
3: That makes it more reasonable. [I am currently considering it for a monolith because Obelisks would use it 6 times per turn.]

[ralouf]

Good idea for water but should be balanced maybe and we need more precison.

Time obelisk is just OP OP OP just imagine that you have one on the board you will kill lava golem deck or pesty deck.. Just OP