The Witch's Game 4

[UTAlan]

More food for thought. Marcia was in the diner's cart last time we saw her before she died, yes?

In a bold attempt, he managed to lure one of the demons in the diner's cart towards a blood ritual; a ritual so bad that the horror alone would cause all of them to implode into nothingness. It worked like a charm, and he had no qualms creating a tempest to scatter the elements - he no longer had a need for teleportation, for his powers had grown ten-fold as a result of the chaos.

So he used something to entice her into the driver's cart, then the first murder took place. I'm guessing she tried to flee and the murderer was waiting outside the door. He goes in and kills her and the other driver, taking damage himself (per the italicized section after the above quote). I don't know how to make that specific enough for white text, but maybe someone else can use this to help.

[Fippe94]

Someone was unknowingly given something poisonous from the murderer. That person entered the driver's cart and the drivers ate this poisonous thing and died. Marcia and the person opened the door to escape but then the murderer entered the room instead and killed Marcia.

Repeat this:
Only 3 person died in the driver's cart.
Only Marcia, the drivers, the murderer and you was ever inside the driver's cart.
No one in the driver's cart was killed with poison.

[Kuroaitou]

Someone was unknowingly given something poisonous from the murderer. That person entered the driver's cart and the drivers ate this poisonous thing and died. Marcia and the person opened the door to escape but then the murderer entered the room instead and killed Marcia.

Neither of the drivers ate anything poisonous while on the train.

Repeat this:
Only 3 person died in the driver's cart.
Only Marcia, the drivers, the murderer and you was ever inside the driver's cart.
No one in the driver's cart was killed with poison.

Okay?
Only 3 person died in the driver's cart.
Only Marcia, the drivers, the murderer and you was ever inside the driver's cart.
No one in the driver's cart was killed with poison.

*coughs* 

[Fippe94]

Damien was unknowingly given something poisonous from the murderer. Damien then entered the driver's cart and ate this poisonous thing and died. Marcia and the drivers opened the door to escape but then the murderer entered the room instead and killed them. He then broke the windshield and threw out Damien body through it.

[Kuroaitou]

Damien was unknowingly given something poisonous from the murderer. Damien then entered the driver's cart and ate this poisonous thing and died. Marcia and the drivers opened the door to escape but then the murderer entered the room instead and killed them. He then broke the windshield and threw out Damien body through it.

In conjunction:

Damien did not die in the driver's cart.

Damien never ate anything poisonous.

[UTAlan]

After the first murder, Marcia opened the door to escape, but then the murderer entered the room instead and killed everyone in the driver's cart who was still alive (except himself)

[Kuroaitou]

After the first murder, Marcia opened the door to escape, but then the murderer entered the room instead and killed everyone in the driver's cart who was still alive (except himself)

The murderer did not enter the driver's cart until Marcia was dead.

[UTAlan]

Are these consistent? (in bold white, just in case)

Marcia was in the same room as the culprit when she was killed.

The murderer did not enter the driver's cart until Marcia was dead.

[Kuroaitou]

Yes.

[eaglgenes101]

I take it from the above that either room != cart, or culpurit != murderer. Which one?

[UTAlan]

Or Marcia wasn't murdered in the driver's cart. He dragged her body in after killing her?

[Fippe94]

Richard entered the VIP bathroom while Terry was right outside. While the bathroom door was open, the murderer came and killed them both.