I fail to see why you can't be both.
A true RPG is in the making. A plot has been made, with several side plots, complete with a balanced character maker. I just need to make a map. I do not wish to use this one, largely because of it's "uncharted shore", but I doubt people would like using my ASCII map either, although I have it. If I ever get around to it, I'd like to make a map based upon the synergy polls in each element, that's what they're there for. To make a war map. It should be a hex map, and for that reason, I tried to collect the six top synergies. Ideas I have for it:
The world is made of four layers. The Aetherian dimension, the city of clouds, the middle world, and the underworld.
The Aetherian dimension is actually just a sphere, surrounded by the vast emptiness. Perhaps the void? Either way, there are six gates to get there, the dimension gates. There's on near every element that aether has the best synergy with.
The city of clouds is a rag-tag group of clouds, flown between the two because all of the air elementals can fly. You can only get up or down with updrafts, otherwise flying downward would either take to long, cause you to stall, have no landing zone, or a combination of the three. Climbing up is impossible without one.
The underworld has darkness, death, and earth. The only way between those are to use tunnels.
The middle world has everything else.
The synergies are, in order:
Aether: Did not make the thread
Air: Life, Fire, Light, Water/Death, Aether. Thread unfair, the option for mono was added
Darkness: Death, Aether, Earth, Entropy. The rest is inconclusive
Death: Did not make the thread
Earth: Did not make the thread
Entropy: Darkness, Gravity, Life, Aether, Death, Time/Light/Earth.
Fire: Earth, Aether, Air, Death, Gravity, Light
Gravity: Did not make the thread
Life: Aether, Air, Light, Water, Darkness/Entropy
Light: Aether, Life, Air, Fire, Earth/Darkness/Water
Time: Aether, Earth, Gravity, Life, Light, Darkness
Water: Death, Aether, Air, Life, Fire, Earth
I don't expect it to be perfect, but I'd love if all elements were nearby elements they have synergy with.