Elements Mafia 62 - by Solaris

[Linkcat]

So my first thought upon seeing the Nightkill is that Dema is basically confirmed. This was a poor attempt by mafia to frame Dema by killing another really old player. The mistake they made is that they killed a player who I pointed out several times as being useless, which made it really obvious that they killed him for a specific reason. The other option is that Dema is actually framing himself in a poor way hoping that I would make this exact post. That would be hilarious, but I'm not disregarding it. I could definitely see Ryli+dawn making those kills, so I want to lynch dawn to see if Ryli made the rookie mistake of defending her own partner.

fabian771 (1) - iancudorinmarian
iancudorinmarian (2) - Ryli, CleanOnion
Ryli (1) - Demagog
dawn to dusk (1) - Linkcat

If this was a fake Artemis, surely they would have gone for a better target than dawn? It feels like a really believable target to me.

[Solaris]

Parentheses don't work with 8 votes

(8)

SWAG

MLG

420

[iancudorinmarian]

Parentheses don't work with 8 votes

(8)

SWAG

MLG

420

Get out

[Espithel]

So my first thought upon seeing the Nightkill is that Dema is basically confirmed. This was a poor attempt by mafia to frame Dema by killing another really old player. The mistake they made is that they killed a player who I pointed out several times as being useless, which made it really obvious that they killed him for a specific reason. The other option is that Dema is actually framing himself in a poor way hoping that I would make this exact post. That would be hilarious, but I'm not disregarding it. I could definitely see Ryli+dawn making those kills, so I want to lynch dawn to see if Ryli made the rookie mistake of defending her own partner.

fabian771 (1) - iancudorinmarian
iancudorinmarian (2) - Ryli, CleanOnion
Ryli (1) - Demagog
dawn to dusk (1) - Linkcat

If this was a fake Artemis, surely they would have gone for a better target than dawn? It feels like a really believable target to me.

If ryli/dawn is mafia, why would the mafia explicitly out one of their candidates?

I smell a redirection trick, personally. I think something said in the previous night must've struck a nerve with one of the mafia.

[Linkcat]

Dawn's not going to be mafia if Yogurt is Artemis.

[iancudorinmarian]

Dawn's not going to be mafia if Yogurt is Artemis.

Don't you mean it the other way around?

[Espithel]

... Okay, I'll take the bait.

fabian771 {1} - iancudorinmarian
iancudorinmarian {2} - Ryli, CleanOnion
Ryli {1} - Demagog
dawn to dusk {2} - Linkcat, Espithel

[Linkcat]

Yes, iancu.

[killsdazombies]

<Finally decides that since link humored him, to start playing seriously.
<Starts writing post for day 2. Time to rock and roll.
<4 paragraphs in, gets to the night kill for night 1
<fml. Ripme


Blarg

[CleanOnion]

If this was a fake Artemis, surely they would have gone for a better target than dawn? It feels like a really believable target to me.

Wouldn't that be exactly why dawn was picked?

Assuming the Artemis is fake, mafia would be trying to balance "picking off a valuable player" and "not picking a player valuable enough that it's not believable".

Apply your logic to a genuine Artemis. Why pick d2d? Why not someone active?

So my first thought upon seeing the Nightkill is that Dema is basically confirmed. This was a poor attempt by mafia to frame Dema by killing another really old player.

That's a very specific rationale you have there. I think we all know that Dema would kill whoever he pleases. He may say he doesn't know us well, but I'm sure he's more than capable of killing people normally like a normal person.

Your willingness to snuggle Dema under the blanket of confirmedness throws suspicion on both of you.

[Linkcat]

Claiming Artemis on the noticeboard is already risky, so on the chance people fall for it it's a lot better to kill a more active player. The extra reward outweighs the extra risk.

What you said about Dema doesn't go against anything that I said.

[CleanOnion]

The nightkill targeting d2d in no way confirms Demagog, that's what I'm saying.

I'm also saying that it throws sus on you for suggesting it.

fabian771 {1} - iancudorinmarian
iancudorinmarian {1} - Ryli
Ryli {1} - Demagog
dawn to dusk {2} - Linkcat, Espithel
Linkcat {1} - CleanOnion