Ebwop: <3 Onion. I actually just missed your name when looking through the list and was too lazy to move people down one slot. I'd put you somewhere in the middle.
Yeah you belong at the top of that list
The game started with two A Rock With A Note's... right? I recall from a recent game with a VERY similar mechanic that these CAN be used investigatively.
Holders of the rocks should toss them to players not likely to be nk'ed and a town recipient of a rock should immediately toss it back to the thrower if the thrower is a town player (mafia have no reason to throw ANY rocks as far add I can discern). Also, receiving a rock and not tossing it back I think should be considered scummy until explained otherwise.
Thoughts comments on this?
What's stopping mafia from just throwing the rock right back?
If mafia has no reasons to throw a rock, then neither does town. If not throwing a rock is scummy, then if anything, mafia have even greater reason to throw a rock than town.
That is, unless Rocks With Notes contains a list of all players by whom it was thrown. However, to my understanding, it doesn't do that.
As Dema says, it's literally a poke. I'd need circumstances in which this would be useful explained to me.