Elements Mafia 61 - by Linkcat

[CleanOnion]

Apathy? In this mafia? Linkcat wouldn't stand for that.

Hyroen (2) - Kuroaitou, CleanOnion

[DoubleCapitals]

Do people still get MK for inactivity if so then shouldn't we lynch someone else

[Naii_the_Baf]

They still get modkilled for inactivity.

We still need information. I support Kuro.

Hyroen (3) - Kuroaitou, CleanOnion, fabian771

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Do people still get MK for inactivity if so then shouldn't we lynch someone else

If Hyro is civvy, and we lynch him for inactivity, it's simply a wasted day of lynching.
If Hyro is mafia, and we lynch him for inactivity, yay - although it's unlikely he'll allow this to happen, so at least starting a lynch train on him will force him to speak, so we might read him.
If we allow Hyro to die to inactivity, it achieves the exact same thing, but we get our lynch back, and have the chance of lynching a mafia.

TL/DR, we should leave the train on Hyro at 3, rather than piling on. This allows him to be under pressure, but means we won't get a situation where he posts late in the day and not enough people log on in time to reverse the lynch, should we like what he says. However, we should keep discussion going on potential other lynch targets, because if he's going to die from inactivity anyway, we should take the opportunity to use our power of lynching by choosing someone who isn't already marked for death.

[Hyroen]

Do people still get MK for inactivity if so then shouldn't we lynch someone else

Yes, they do. I've already been warned about it.

I've been trying to analyze what people post because I've basically been dead in the Mafia scene and haven't played in quite a while. So naturally, I wouldn't want to point out fingers without having some rationale.

If we know that Sera is town, I'd be inclined to lynch whoever has voted to lynch her instead. With no information, I'm not sure if less activity than others is the best criteria with which to lynch.

Either way, what JCJ points out makes perfect sense and I'd argue that Kuro has played enough Mafias to know this.

Hm.

Edit: accidentally credited DC instead of JCJ.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Do people still get MK for inactivity if so then shouldn't we lynch someone else

Yes, they do. I've already been warned about it.

I've been trying to analyze what people post because I've basically been dead in the Mafia scene and haven't played in quite a while. So naturally, I wouldn't want to point out fingers without having some rationale.

If we know that Sera is town, I'd be inclined to lynch whoever has voted to lynch her instead. With no information, I'm not sure if less activity than others is the best criteria with which to lynch.

Either way, what JCJ points out makes perfect sense and I'd argue that Kuro has played enough Mafias to know this.

Hm.

Edit: accidentally credited DC instead of JCJ.

6.   You are not allowed to edit AND/OR remove your post. Instead, EBWOP will take effect. This means, to edit your post, post again with the correct fixes.

Don't edit posts, regardless of typo, always post a second post

[Espithel]

Edit: accidentally credited DC instead of JCJ.

Don't edit your posts.
Instead, make a new post with your edits.

Pretty srs mafia rule 'ere.

[Hyroen]

Urps. My bad.

My edit mark says what I did. As you can tell, it's been a while.

[CleanOnion]

Lynching whoever voted for Sera is silly because none of knew if skyironsword was lying or not.

If skyironsword were alive, it would mean that she would be a valid lynch candidate as well. So that's a stupid strategy.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Lynching whoever voted for Sera is silly because none of knew if skyironsword was lying or not.

If skyironsword were alive, it would mean that she would be a valid lynch candidate as well. So that's a stupid strategy.

I explained several times how Sera was almost certainly civvy as soon as Sky claimed she was. It went something like this:

If sky was civvy, and claimed Sera was civvy, sera was civvy.
If sky was mafia, and claimed Sera was civvy, that would link the two of them together, so that if sky was ever lynched, sera would soon follow. This meant that it would be insane for the both of them to be mafia, hence, if Sky was mafia, Sera would almost certainly be civvy.

I think at the very least taking a hard look at those who voted for Sera after sky said she was town is a good idea.

[andretimpa]

My ability was blocked last night.

I agree with Kuro on this one, would you care to elaborate?

[worldwideweb3]

My thoughts on everyone (list based on sign up list):

Solaris: wrecked espi right at the start with no valid reason whatsoever. Nothing useful i could find in his posts, looks like he is just roleplaying.
Kuro: His ability reveal is a bad option. If he hadnt revealed, mafia would have nk'ed and it would be helpful to civvies if that happened (according to kuro's ability).  Pushing hyro only for some reason. He has, though, tried to make conversations and get more info off people, which is good. Voted on sub.
JCJ: Again, tried to get some discussion going. Not roleplaying much, which is good.
onion: umm, he just roleplayed. I literally have nothing except from that. Voted on sub (more so cause self defence)
mathman: Pretty similar to onion Did put up the RQS though.
gino: afk
espithel: lost his ability, cant vote. Claimed Jester, so i guess we shouldnt lynch him, just to make him suffer. But, could be mafia fake claiming.
Fippe94: Would rather win than roleplay (yay), but didnt post much till now. Voted on sub.
UT: Took his vote off onion last minute to lynch sub (nothing much to go on atm, but just a thing for future). Voted on 1011.... at the start to put some pressure/get discussion.
Kills: nothing relevant posted. voted on sub.
Root: Has a posting restriction apprently that he has to shitpost (i really doubt this, but then again, linkcat is the host). Really hated sub for some reason. People need to play mafia with a neutral mind, as if they havent met anyone before :/. voted on sub.
fabian: nothing relevant. havent posted much.
DC: questioned a couple people, nothing much that stands out.
Calindu: He's even playing?! Must have missed his posts.
d2d: nothing relevant or much posted.
1011...: same ^, kinda new to it, so excusable a bit, i guess.
andre: Posted a bit, voted on sol after hearing sol's ability use on espi, then removed it after hearing sol's reason.
rob: posted a lot, as usual, trying to get discussions going. voted on sub.
Hyro: hasnt talked much
Sera: conf. town pretty much. Go go sera!

Warning: 40 pages read and commenting on each is difficult, so might have missed something. If so, do let me know!