Wall | Great Wall

[Smurrf]

2nd change.  Increased cost for both from 4 to 5 ; I also removed the ability for ranged weapons to be blocked.  Thoughts before it goes up for Crucible?

[Flayne]

2nd change.  Increased cost for both from 4 to 5 ; I also removed the ability for ranged weapons to be blocked.  Thoughts before it goes up for Crucible?

According to my formula thats actually way too cheap, 6 damage?
new formula according to this scenario:

DS

3 dmg for 3 
+ 1 for all creatures (0.5 for air, 0.5 for ground)
+ 1 for all weapons  (0.5 for range, 0.5 for non-range)
+ 1 for constant.   
= 6 


GW

6 damage for 6
+ 0.5 for ground creatures only
+ 0.5 for non-range weapons only
+ 1 for constant

= 8 

I could say -1 for flying weapons, which would have a cost 7

but you are suggesting it cost 5?
too cheap imo.

[OldTrees]

Too Cheap.

Shields cost X +1card +shield slot = (X+4)q

Dimensional Shield vs Wings
Cost: 6 |5 vs 4 |3
Effect: 3 turn protection vs 5 turn non airborne/ranged protection
3/(6+4)=3/10 vs 5/(4+4)=5/8 non airborne/ranged
24:50 or ~1:2 ratio
Titanium Shield vs Wall
Cost: 4 |6 vs X |Y
Effect: DR 2|3 vs DR 4|6 non airborne/ranged
Higher DR is worth more than just a multiple of lower DR however the multiple gives us a lower estimate or 4 |6 .

I would personally suggest 5 |8

[Smurrf]

Changed the cost as suggested.