Voting: Shard Revolution (Final Phase)

[Haltar Dhrim]

Why didn't you listed my Fire Shard?

Shard of Courage (http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,28846.msg395150#msg395150)

[Kuroaitou]

Why didn't you listed my Fire Shard?

Shard of Courage (http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,28846.msg395150#msg395150)

Corrected and added.

[Haltar Dhrim]

Ok thanks alot!

[Gocubbies1212]

so we are allowed to advertise our shards in this topic?

[Jenkar]

so we are allowed to advertise our shards in this topic?

Totally, as long as you respect forum rules (ie quadruple posting "Vote my shard" is not allowed)

[Gocubbies1212]

awesome!

vote Shard of Will in the  section!

Link:  http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,29418.0.html

[teffy]

My opinion to most of the shards: They are totally OP for an "Other" card.

[Jenkar]

My opinion to most of the shards: They are totally OP for an "Other" card.

Rest of my opinions (which guided my "worthy" on first page) :

• They are too dependant on their element
• They don't fit their element
• They have an unclear/bad/mispelled mechanism

[TheManuz]

My opinion to most of the shards: They are totally OP for an "Other" card.

Rest of my opinions (which guided my "worthy" on first page) :

• They are too dependant on their element
• They don't fit their element
• They have an unclear/bad/mispelled mechanism

I mostly agree.
Anyway, i recognize that making a balanced card with clear mechanism and a fitting flavor, that also gives a bonus to an element without being too much element-driven is an hard task.
Everyone made his best, or maybe just give a try, but often cards need feedbacks from the community to improve machanics/balancing/flavor. But this is a competition, so there is no feedback. It's just you and the card.

[Jenkar]

My opinion to most of the shards: They are totally OP for an "Other" card.

Rest of my opinions (which guided my "worthy" on first page) :

• They are too dependant on their element
• They don't fit their element
• They have an unclear/bad/mispelled mechanism

I mostly agree.
Anyway, i recognize that making a balanced card with clear mechanism and a fitting flavor, that also gives a bonus to an element without being too much element-driven is an hard task.

Complete agreeal. But dis is mostly for fun/testing your card design, no ?

Everyone made his best, or maybe just give a try, but often cards need feedbacks from the community to improve machanics/balancing/flavor. But this is a competition, so there is no feedback. It's just you and the card.

You can always recycle your ideas after.
Also, anyone that would have/has asked me criticism before voting started would get/has gotten it. It's a competition, but i think that help would still be produced if asked.

[moomoose]

voted for: knowledge - grace - courage - resilience - equality - strength - coop - empathy

[Hyroen]

Total derps

Aether: At least 1 typo.
Air: At least 3 typos.       ._.
Darkness: One odd lowercase letter, at least 1 typo and some weird apostrophe action going on.
Earth: Nothing as far as the eye can see.
Entropy: Nothing as far as the eye can see.
Fire: Didn't get the unupgraded usefulness memo.
Gravity:Uses past tense oddly. At least 1 typo and likes to use slang (2 typos). Didn't get the unupgraded usefulness memo.
Water: At least 1 typo. Not a friend of equality. Didn't get the unupgraded usefulness memo.

Have fun. ^_^