Card Design Competition: Card Using a New Passive Ability

[Scaredgirl]

It appears they want to disqualify my idea because its like yours.

Do you consider my idea too much like yours that it would impinge on your idea in this competition?

I'm wondering how this ruling will affect the content of the crucible.
Various submitions are closer in comparrison than yours(twinbusters) and mine.

Seems like you are still not getting my point.

I'm not talking about cards in Elements, or card ideas in our "Card Ideas and Art" section. There are similarities with those which is fine. I'm talking about this particular card idea competition. You are free to post this idea in the "Card Ideas" section, but for this competition it's too similar to what twinbusters posted earlier.

Lets put it this way. If Zanz implemented this kind of card, which of these two would get to go to Reliquary? Both of them? Think about it and you will hopefully understand the similarities. But even if you don't, it doesn't even matter. I'm the competition organizer here and it's ultimately my call.

Your passive ability "Undead" is of course perfectly fine. You only need to change/tweak that card, and there are a million different possible "Undead" cards. Lets not make a big deal out of this.

If you want to further discuss about my ruling, use PM's.

[Kael Hate]

Since my other entry has been prohibit - Another offering.

Passive Ability - "Undead"

Eternal Servitude| Eternal Servitude  
(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,9767.msg125018.html#msg125018)

"Undead" Undead is a trait noting a creature as having an undead quality. Undead creatures do not trigger graveyards or like abilities. Creatures in the game that would be Undead Bone Dragon Ivory Dragon Skeleton Elite Skeleton Mummy Elite Mummy Minor Vampire Vampire

[Scaredgirl]

Since my other entry has been prohibit - Another offering.

That won't work either because now you are using two passive abilities when others are using only one, which might give you an unfair advantage.

One submission per contestant. That's the system we use with all competitions. In this case one submission means:

- one passive ability
- one card idea

[Kael Hate]

Since my other entry has been prohibit - Another offering.

That won't work either because now you are using two passive abilities when others are using only one, which might give you an unfair advantage.

One submission per contestant. That's the system we use with all competitions. In this case one submission means:

- one passive ability
- one card idea

SERIOUSLY?!

Whats the judgement for here, the Passive ability or the Card?

[twinsbuster]

oh...
anyway I love the art
the skeletons are laughing at me

[Scaredgirl]

Since my other entry has been prohibit - Another offering.

That won't work either because now you are using two passive abilities when others are using only one, which might give you an unfair advantage.

One submission per contestant. That's the system we use with all competitions. In this case one submission means:

- one passive ability
- one card idea

SERIOUSLY?!

Whats the judgement for here, the Passive ability or the Card?

Yeah, seriously.

Your submission uses two new passive abilities. This competition allows only one, just like it allows only 1 card idea. I'm surprised that this is news to you because it's the same system we've been using even since this section came alive.

If you want to use two passive abilities, only way to do that is to use your own idea + Airborne/Ranged (passive abilities that already exist in the game).

[Kael Hate]

*sigh*

Edited entry.

1 Card.
1 Passive Ability.
Not like anyone elses in anyway.

[Antagon]

http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,9772.0.html (http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,9772.0.html)

[guolin]

Original Thread: http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,9770.0.html

Copy and Pasta:

NAME: Illusions ELEMENT: COST: 3 TYPE: Spell ABILITY: All magicians appear as a random creature from your hand to the other player. They still function as normal.	NAME: Refined Illusions ELEMENT: COST: 5 TYPE: Spell ABILITY: Your magicians appear as a random creature from your hand to the other player. They still function as normal.

ART: http://www.guzer.com/pictures/old_people_illusion.jpg IDEA: Guolin NOTES: Here's how this works: The magicians appear to "die" and a random creature from your hand is "summoned." However, nothing really died or summoned, and the "illusion" that is "summoned" still deals damage and activates abilities. However, it appears to "do damage" as if it was really the "illusion." This card is made for the Card Using a New Passive Ability Competition. It relies on a new passive ability, "Magician." Cards that have this ability:  : Maxwell's Demon, Fallen Elf, Purple Nymph, and their upgraded forms.  : Grey Nymph and her upgraded form.  : Graviton Fire Eater, Amber Nymph, and their upgraded forms.  : Auburn Numph and her upgraded form.  : Forest Spirit, Green Nymph, and their upgraded forms.  : Fire Spirit, Phoenix, Red Nymph, and their upgraded forms.  : Mind Flayer, Nymph Queen, and their upgraded forms.  : White Nymph and her upgraded form.  : Blue Nymph and her upgraded form.  : Deja Vu, Anubis, Goldem Nymph, and their upgraded forms.  : Gargoyle (Stone form removes Magician), Black Nymph, and their upgraded forms.  : Immortal, Turqouise Nymph, and their upgraded forms. I can see Entropy monos and Entropy/Water duos using this card. SERIES: N/A N/A

[Kael Hate]

Edited entry again

1 Card.
1 Passive Ability.
No new status effect.
Not like anyone elses in anyway.

[Glaviga]

Passive ability: Wounded
all creatures have this below max health

(http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,9781.0.html)

[Scaredgirl]

Salvage is a special ability that creates a Battle Gear (or War Gear) card in your hand (space allowing) when the creature affected dies.  I guess technically that's two new passive abilities in this card, but Humanoid is the central one.  8)

Only one new passive ability per submission. You need to make changes to your card.

One passive ability.
One card.