Transdimensional Chill | Transdimensional Chill

[Kamietsu]

NAME: Transdimensional Chill ELEMENT: Water COST: 4 TYPE: Spell ATK|HP: TEXT: All protected or immaterial creatures and permanents are frozen for 1 turn.	NAME: Transdimensional Chill ELEMENT: Water COST: 3 TYPE: Spell ATK|HP: TEXT: All protected or immaterial creatures and permanents are frozen for 1 turn.

ART: Kamietsu, with art from Elements. IDEA: Kamietsu NOTES: It does stack if multiple ones are used. If a shield is frozen, none of the shields effects happen, creatures and other sources of damage pass right through it uninhibited. If any other permanent is frozen, it simply isn't able to be activated or activates by itself. Anything with a countdown on it(sundial, dimensional shield) will not count down. The timer will be frozen as well until it is unfrozen. Haven't decided if it should affect the entire field or just your opponent's side. SERIES:

[Jocko]

What about unupped whole field and upped enemy field?

[Kamietsu]

that's a darn good idea.

[bogtro]

Excellent excellent idea. Finally a counter to immaterial stuff.

[n00b]

Someone find my seal of approval... 'cause this idea totally gets it!

[maverixk]

I would lower the cost by one for unupped and upped, because while it does freeze ALL of them, it's only for one turn. Sundial costs much less and does this same effect (more or less) for 1

[RRQJ]

sundial doesn't prevent ability usage, though.  Also, this card can affect permanents.

[Hyroen]

No likey name. Lovely concept though. Hope it doesn't cross over into the plans of the upcoming Water themed Shard.

[NikaZaslavsky]

Perfect card for discouraging immortality. Also, you should definitely use Jocko's idea.

[RRQJ]

The only concern I have is that it's usefulness is dependent on your opponent.  If they don't have any PAs, quints, immortal creatures/permanents, then this card is useless and wastes a draw.

[Xenocidius]

The only concern I have is that it's usefulness is dependent on your opponent.  If they don't have any PAs, quints, immortal creatures/permanents, then this card is useless and wastes a draw.

Not necessarily - it has synergy with Turquoise Nymph/Anubis.

[TheManuz]

The only concern I have is that it's usefulness is dependent on your opponent.  If they don't have any PAs, quints, immortal creatures/permanents, then this card is useless and wastes a draw.

This is my main concern too.
Maybe add another effect that is unrelated to immaterial/protected, so the card is useful anyway but is better against immaterial/protected.
Something like

Add 1 turn of freeze to frozen creatures and permanents. All protected or immaterial creatures and permanents are frozen for 1 turn.