If a creature dies by your shield does that count as a death caused by you? This card is definitely an original idea, but I feel sort of meh with it, feels uncontrolled, I don't know. Anyone else have thoughts?
I think it's a little too situational. I mean, it's an indirect way to protect your creatures, but I don't like the way it gives your opponent the choice to kill or not, and I don't see any new deck ideas coming out of this card.