I think the un-upped version actually has some utility as a count to mass cc, even as is. Although you will take damage from RoF or Pandemonium, other mass CC is negated. E.g. thunderstorm, and gas are negated by healing. Even plague will only be dangerous after several applications. In fact, mass creatures + gas + this = up to 23 healing.
I think this could be quite effective in a Fractal RoL deck even left as is. Even against RoF, 1 damage per creature isn't that huge of a price to pay to keep your shield high.
One thing though, will mirror shield subsequently redirect damage to your opponent... that would be EXTREMELY powerful (probably way OP in fact if you consider the unupped pandemonium + fractal combo).
I don't know about the upped version though. If i want to convert incoming damage to , i think solar shield is a safer bet.
1. I have mentioned that the bonus is only given once for each creature. So the mass healing can only be given once.
Maybe I use an example to explain this :
Play divine protection, and I have 3 creatures. I gain 6 HP. Then I play one more creature , one more creature is under my protection, so I gain 2 more HP
2. Mirror shield cannot reflect the damage
3. For the upped version, you can gain
immediately when you play the card to protect creatures, so you can gain up to 23
in one single turn, more than enough to power a Miracle
i am not aware of the Red herring. what is that??
It's a creature card. When it is on field, opponent can only target it.
Somehow I can't find the link to the card