Brawl #1 - Round 4 [Voting Phase]

[UTAlan]

Yeah, for artist next time I think that it should be clarified if you just had to rework the artwork or the entire card, as 2 submissions did.

3 submissions did that, not only 2. Artist #2 (Firefly Queen -> Vampire King), Artist #4 (Lava Golem -> Ice Golem) and Artist #6 (Immolation -> Sacrifice). The other three, Artist #1 (Fate Egg -> Fate Egg), Artist #3 (Guardian Angel -> Disfigured Angel) and Artist #5 (Crusader -> Dark Crusader) have only changed card's name & element.

It was only required to change the art and element, but reworking the entire card was not forbidden.

Why does off-topicker have 6 spoilers, 2 empty with 4 voting options, while forum expert has 4 spoilers, with 6 voting options? o:

This has been fixed. Due to what appears to be a copy/paste error which left off the last 2 Forum Expert entries, the FE poll has been reset. I have added 12 hours to the deadline in order to give the 11 people who voted in this poll the opportunity to re-vote. My deepest apologies.

[ARTHANASIOS]

It was only required to change the art and element, but reworking the entire card was not forbidden.

The problem here is about the way we are going to judge the Artist submissions. Do we take into account ONLY the quality of each art or do we vote for the best art AND best card rework?

[UTAlan]

It was only required to change the art and element, but reworking the entire card was not forbidden.

The problem here is about the way we are going to judge the Artist submissions. Do we take into account ONLY the quality of each art or do we vote for the best art AND best card rework?

The art, please.

[ARTHANASIOS]

The art, please.

Thank you. This is going to make the judging criteria much more certain.

[ddevans96]

So you post the cards and expect people to only vote for the art?

If it's about the art just have people submit the art and nothing else.

[ARTHANASIOS]

So you post the cards and expect people to only vote for the art?

If it's about the art just have people submit the art and nothing else.

The truth is it wasn't clarified if the round #4 Artists should focus in their art or their mechanics. As a result, we have 3 submissions which are obviously at an advantage and 3 at a disadvantage.

[vrt]

So you post the cards and expect people to only vote for the art?

If it's about the art just have people submit the art and nothing else.

The truth is it wasn't clarified if the round #4 Artists should focus in their art or their mechanics. As a result, we have 3 submissions which are obviously at an advantage and 3 at a disadvantage.

The rules stated Redraw/Modify the card art for the new element. Modifying the actual card is basically using a crutch.

[drolly]

Why does off-topicker have 6 spoilers, 2 empty with 4 voting options, while forum expert has 4 spoilers, with 6 voting options? o:

This has been fixed.

Thanks for fixing Off-Topicker, but Forum Expert still looks buggy. Now I can see 6 poll options, the first 4 submissions look well (however, the link in #4 doesn't work), the 5th only consists of

Table Conversion Tool&

and the last one seems to have vanished again.

By the way, thanks for adding team names to the earlier submissions!

The art, please.

Bumping this; it made me change my vote as I had based it on more criteria than just the art before.

[ARTHANASIOS]

The rules stated Redraw/Modify the card art for the new element. Modifying the actual card is basically using a crutch.

True, but since the label continues like this "The community will be encouraged to vote for the best representation and originality" it is quite easy for participants to think that "originality" has to do with both art and card mechanics. After all, you can't keep a card completely the same after changing its element. For example, the angel has interesting art, but an entropic angelic creature with an in-element healing effect just doesn't fit (no offence to the artist, he/she made an impressive art)...
However, I  have already mentioned that I will pay respect to the voting criteria and I hope the rest of the voters will do the same.

[TheonlyrealBeef]

Why does off-topicker have 6 spoilers, 2 empty with 4 voting options, while forum expert has 4 spoilers, with 6 voting options? o:

This has been fixed. Due to what appears to be a copy/paste error which left off the last 2 Forum Expert entries, the FE poll has been reset. I have added 12 hours to the deadline in order to give the 11 people who voted in this poll the opportunity to re-vote. My deepest apologies.

Am I blind or do I still only see

Table Conversion Tool&

for submission 5 and no 6th submission for forum expert? xD

Maybe the post is too long and the rest gets cut off?

[UTAlan]

Thanks to Chrome for keeping the original post in cache, I was able to update it and get it working correctly. Please let me know if you notice any other errors. Again, sorry for the inconvenience.

[ARTHANASIOS]

Forum expert has still submissions 1 to 3 while there are 6 voting options.