Able to thumbs up decks you beat as well

[furballdn]

First off, let me try and make myself clear. Give the ability to thumbs up or thumbs down decks you beat in the arena, but regardless of what you do, their rank and rating loss is the same. The only thing that happens if you thumbs up a deck you beat, is that they gain a small reward for being creative. All too often you meet a super awesome deck and would love to thumbs it up, but you beat it. If everyone thumbs down boring ghostmares that beat you, I think people should also have the option to thumbs up decks that they win against but are really creative or nice.

Pros: Would help inspire more creativity in decks and make people build decks that aren't just purely made to win with boring tactics
Cons: May lessen creativity since some people will just make farms/bad decks for the compensatory reward

[Absol]

This has been suggested before. Either way, i agree. Maybe thumbing up the deck you beat gives half the money it gain if it win.
Even for farm, 6 gold per loss (in Plat) is not much, and you will likely only get 18 gold before it dropped out (if you still need money anyway)

[Rutarete]

I like this idea.

[Annele]

This has been suggested before. Either way, i agree. Maybe thumbing up the deck you beat gives half the money it gain if it win.
Even for farm, 6 gold per loss (in Plat) is not much, and you will likely only get 18 gold before it dropped out (if you still need money anyway)

This.

[Holokausti]

Why not, I feel like I'd give more easily thumb ups if I had beaten the deck. Too much of time I just thumb down cause losing ain't fun.

[DoubleCapitals]

I'm against this idea.
We shouldn't reward bad decks.

[Annele]

I'm against this idea.
We shouldn't reward bad decks.

It's about rewarding a creativedeck that may have lost because of hp decay.

[DoubleCapitals]

Hp decay is there to encourage people to make new decks. I think the present rewrad is enough for now.

[memimemi]

I like this idea very much.  Oftentimes, I'll face a deck that's simply amazing, but the AI is unable to play it effectively.  It would be nice to have a quick way to show some appreciation for the creators of decks that give me combo ideas, even if the AI doesn't get how to use them.

[TheManuz]

I'm for giving thumbs down or nothing when i win (if I give you a thumbs down even after I won, your deck must be really awful!) and thumbs up or nothing when I lose (if I thumbs up even after losing, your deck must be really fun!).

[furballdn]

I'm against this idea.
We shouldn't reward bad decks.

This is for promoting more creativity. If we only wanted "good" decks in the arena, there'd be even more ghostmares, firestalls, mono aether/death/darkness than there already is. The thumbs system was implemented to discourage those.

[Captain Scibra]

I like this idea, as I do have this dilemma a lot.  Maybe giving it a thumbs up halves the loss of rating?

Hp decay is there to encourage people to make new decks. I think the present rewrad is enough for now.

This is hardly relevant.  Promoting new does not necessarily mean promoting creativity.