War #9 - Round 8

[Spielkind]

War #9 - Suggestions and Feedback

Please post suggestions and feedback regarding War #9 in this thread for War #10's benefit

Its for the next war, spike.

And sorry but i would say stop complaining to all of you and start being wm yourself next war. I think this EC should get a shot, will not be that bad everyone is thinking. And when it is, then Feedback after seeing what happened.

I think its a funny EC. So just lets have fun and win your matches. So nothing will happen.

Edit: this was adressed to all supporters of changing the current ec, not Spike alone.

[worldwideweb3]

Do we name it in apm to wms? Otherwise, in the winning post before deadline?... Would seem more work for you this way but prevents secrets.

PM me.

What is the required timing of this PM with the targeted card?  Is it before the match is played or before end of round or before end of deckbuilding phase??

Send me as soon as your match is done, before the deadline for duel phase.

[iancudorinmarian]

Do we name it in apm to wms? Otherwise, in the winning post before deadline?... Would seem more work for you this way but prevents secrets.

PM me.

What is the required timing of this PM with the targeted card?  Is it before the match is played or before end of round or before end of deckbuilding phase??

Send me as soon as your match is done, before the deadline for duel phase.

May I request it to be sent all at the same time by one person (the general, preferably)? A lot easier for you WMs and a lot better for the whole team, otherwise we might just end up having sent a card we don't actually want to discard because we didn't have time to discuss about it.

[Afdarenty]

Will the discarded cards be made public?

[iancudorinmarian]

Will the discarded cards be made public?

They are treated as discards. Discards are secret, so my guess is they aren't made public. Otherwise, it's even more of a punishment for a loss.

[SpikeSpiegel]

Will the discarded cards be made public?

Public = a disaster.

Each team would target a different card.

[Afdarenty]

Will the discarded cards be made public?

Public = a disaster.

Each team would target a different card.

After all discards have been finalised, will the discarded cards be made public?

[worldwideweb3]

Will the discarded cards be made public?

Public = a disaster.

Each team would target a different card.

After all discards have been finalised, will the discarded cards be made public?

No.

[worldwideweb3]

Do we name it in apm to wms? Otherwise, in the winning post before deadline?... Would seem more work for you this way but prevents secrets.

PM me.

What is the required timing of this PM with the targeted card?  Is it before the match is played or before end of round or before end of deckbuilding phase??

Send me as soon as your match is done, before the deadline for duel phase.

May I request it to be sent all at the same time by one person (the general, preferably)? A lot easier for you WMs and a lot better for the whole team, otherwise we might just end up having sent a card we don't actually want to discard because we didn't have time to discuss about it.

Sure. I want them sent a bit before deadline for duel phase so I can make sure the discards are legal (even though it's pretty simple, teams may make a mistake or something)

[iancudorinmarian]

Sure. I want them sent a bit before deadline for duel phase so I can make sure the discards are legal (even though it's pretty simple, teams may make a mistake or something)

Ok, an example then. If I have 4 amethyst pillars in my deck out of 4 that I have in the vault and my opponent chooses it, can I discard them from the deck to "evade" EC or am I forced to discard other cards along with my amethyst pillars from the vault (for a total of 15+4 discards)?

[Zso_Zso]

Sure. I want them sent a bit before deadline for duel phase so I can make sure the discards are legal (even though it's pretty simple, teams may make a mistake or something)

Does that mean we have to send them now (in the next few hours) ?
I was under the impression, that the target card should be named after the match picking a card from the deck the opponent played, but if we have to send it now, then obviously we have no idea what the opponent is playing, so it could be any card we decide to name ?

[iancudorinmarian]

Sure. I want them sent a bit before deadline for duel phase so I can make sure the discards are legal (even though it's pretty simple, teams may make a mistake or something)

Does that mean we have to send them now (in the next few hours) ?
I was under the impression, that the target card should be named after the match picking a card from the deck the opponent played, but if we have to send it now, then obviously we have no idea what the opponent is playing, so it could be any card we decide to name ?

End of duel phase. This is deckbuilding phase.