War #8 - Suggestions and Feedback

[SpikeSpiegel]

@ Deuce: I don't want to start a discussion about War, what I wrote it's just my opinion.

But:

1. I never suggested to use Sacrifice vault rules; I said that we could take inspiration by that kind of vaults.

2. Aether is probably the most balanced element, with several powerful cards; now, not intended to discredit previous aether teams, and if someone is offended can come to me to clarify. But, and it's my opinion, with cards like dim shield, fractal, etc... deckbuilding war rules are a slight advantage for aether. I can explain it better via PM if someone is interested.

3. I'm sorry, but here you failed. I understand your intent to make Generals communicating with applicants, and it would have been perfect with a different auction system; with the current draft, auctions should be the fullest possible. Moreover, the mess here is highlighted by the fact that two different WM's gave me two different answers.


As someone said time ago, in this community there's a lack of innovators; this was the perfect chance to renew War, above all after that disastrous #7. But I guess I've to wait a little bit more to see something new.

Fine to me.

[Vangelios]

deuce, only me and Spike as masters you mean?
well actually I can tolerate the current vault system (although I think it could be a "free vault")
what really makes me mad is the fact of not being able to change the deck during the duel. Make that each player go to the duel with at least 2 decks instead of only 1.

and also I suggest a pool to war as Higurashi did to shards, will help get a better sense of how the community feels the war.

[deuce22]

@Spike, I'm sorry you feel that we "failed" at organizing the auction applications. And if you ask 3 people the same question, chances are you are going to get 3 different answers. If the applications are the only thing we "failed" at, I think we did a pretty damn good job. With all that being said, we may link a template to the application post per DM's suggestion, but it will still not be required.

With regards to lack of innovation, this is an established event that requires small changes from war to war, not complete renovation. And war 7 was not a "disaster" because of vaults or deckbuilding rules. This would imply that all wars have been a disaster.

Thank you for your feedback. Good luck to you and your team this war.

[Vangelios]

Why I cannot to post in propaganda? 

[deuce22]

Why I cannot to post in propaganda? 

post or comment?

[Vangelios]

both but I wanna to comment

Spoiler for Hidden:

[deuce22]

weird, let me see if I can figure that one out

Update: WMs dont have control over access to propaganda. I have no idea why you cant post anything there. I would take it up with Higs.

[Vangelios]

now was solved thanks deuce

[rem4life]

What if a deck that wins against a deck that uses ultrarares (marks/nymphs) has a double salvage or at least something extra for every ultrarare used?

[dawn to dusk]

They receive an alchemy card based on the type of nymph beaten + regular salvages

[Vangelios]

I see some players from outside why the Underworld be convenient now?

However the idea of ​​sub is interesting.

[Zso_Zso]

It would be interesting to see all the drafting lists of all Generals for each round, now that the draft is over.
WMs, please post them.