War #7 - Voices of the Fallen

[rem4life]

I think Marsu did right, why waste time being that the current format of war  never will have chances.

Right or wrong, Marsu had his reasons. Format of event wasn't one of them

[deuce22]

I think Marsu did right, why waste time being that the current format of war  never will have chances.

This was historically true of gravity and light as well. Gravity easily could have won this war, and Light nearly won a few wars ago.

But yeah, the current format does not close the gap between life and the stronger elements. I think there are ways of making war more competitive between elements, but I think an active team with any element has a chance to win war.

[Vangelios]

I think Life may have an active team yes, because will be one of the first to say bye

[deuce22]

I think Life may have an active team yes, because will be one of the first to say bye

I have no idea what you are saying...

[killsdazombies]

What I think he said was that life will always be considered active, because they will be knocked out early.


This I disagree with. During war 2, life got third place, tied for second if you go by round knockout.
Its all about how you build, and sadly, how the rules are formed. Sometimes the rules are against certain elements.

[Vangelios]

I think Life may have an active team yes, because will be one of the first to say bye

I have no idea what you are saying...

will be one of the first teams go out of war or lose the war, then will be easy to team life be active,
since the war will last very little for them.

What I think he said was that life will always be considered active, because they will be knocked out early.
yes

This I disagree with. During war 2, life got third place, tied for second if you go by round knockout.
Its all about how you build, and sadly, how the rules are formed. Sometimes the rules are against certain elements.
sometimes? always in the case of some

[deuce22]

some will agree with you Vang, and some will disagree. You are entitled to your opinion.

But can you clarify what rules are specifically against life? This is an important question to answer so that future wars can be more balanced.

[Vangelios]

. I think we have much to reformulate deuce
course I don't wanna decrease their merit and say that to win war need be in the aether team, is not easy as appears (I agree with you in this point), but is less hard than the vast majority of teams. reformulate this is the key,

 See what happens in the BL and CL only prohibiting shards and allowing dual league? were broken taboos and bring good results
in my view, if the format of war continues stagnant will be similar to CL with few players.

 Yes, some may agree or disagree, this is normal, after all that's how things happen, the important thing is you know that many did not like to see aether win in the same format as advantage, people realize when a system favoring to win.

[dawn to dusk]

Life has potential to be a very strong element. But it depends on how it is built. To start war, I was surprised life didn't choose rustlers as they go well in a lot of decks (RoLtosis, mitodragons, etc) but it does seem to be an unpopular element... (See the amount that chose life in TPvP)

If I could do something to change this war, I would change the starting vault. Not saying its bad, just saying that I would have made some slight modifications to it.

[Laxadarap]

Life has potential to be a very strong element. But it depends on how it is built. To start war, I was surprised life didn't choose rustlers as they go well in a lot of decks (RoLtosis, mitodragons, etc) but it does seem to be an unpopular element... (See the amount that chose life in TPvP)

If I could do something to change this war, I would change the starting vault. Not saying its bad, just saying that I would have made some slight modifications to it.

MANY decks run CC or shields.  Using rustlers pretty much makes your deck into a light/life duo, which not only is weak to cc, but also has no way to deal with shields.

[deuce22]

. I think we have much to reformulate deuce
course I don't wanna decrease their merit and say that to win war need be in the aether team, is not easy as appears (I agree with you in this point), but is less hard than the vast majority of teams. reformulate this is the key,

 See what happens in the BL and CL only prohibiting shards and allowing dual league? were broken taboos and bring good results
in my view, if the format of war continues stagnant will be similar to CL with few players.

 Yes, some may agree or disagree, this is normal, after all that's how things happen, the important thing is you know that many did not like to see aether win in the same format as advantage, people realize when a system favoring to win.

So, to sum up, you think life wil be more competitive if shards are allowed?

[treebeard xiii]

Life has potential to be a very strong element. But it depends on how it is built. To start war, I was surprised life didn't choose rustlers as they go well in a lot of decks (RoLtosis, mitodragons, etc) but it does seem to be an unpopular element... (See the amount that chose life in TPvP)

If I could do something to change this war, I would change the starting vault. Not saying its bad, just saying that I would have made some slight modifications to it.

Life is not a hard element to use it just needs a different approach compared to other elements it benefits more from other elements therefore a large vault is needed so unless it does reasonably early in war meta it will always fall early unlike aether amongst other 'stronger' elements its mono is perhaps one of the weakest whereas other elements can bounce back from 1 or 2 bad rounds the effect of that greatly cripples life I believe water showed that as well after our bad round we never recovered we survived not competed like someone else said realistically any element has a reasonable chance to win war it depends 30% on activity, 40% mindgating, 30% vault and 20% rng and yes i deliberately went to 110% percent.