War #12 - Suggestions and Feedback

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Dust bank is a pretty cool idea actually

[Blacksmith]

Spoiler for Hidden:

A lot of that has to do with other stuff than the player bass. There just isn't that many new card ideas, deck ideas, buff section, nerfing section, grinders to post about. The game has been pretty much the same since 2012. If you look at people online or new members added, it's not as dramatic.

So, regardless of anything else, I personally think the flexible team size is a success. Every player got onto a team and we still have a decent number of matches for each team, regardless of their actual size. I definitely think this is a keeper. We don't have the luxury of an enormous player base, so including everyone that wants to join is good.

+1

One more thing. War usually starts in July or August. Pushing it forward a few months - that was done this time - was a misstake. We should aim to have war 13# starting in July or August.

[Manuel]

lol i played against 4 gens (losing 2 times) in 2 round without saying nothing, now the biggest issue is rework how pairing works

[dawn to dusk]

lol i played against 4 gens (losing 2 times) in 2 round without saying nothing, now the biggest issue is rework how pairing works

So have we, so has Earth, so has Death, it's not an uncommon occurrence to play 4 Gens in 2 Rounds. And we all did it without the SEC reducing Gen upgrades. That's not what I'm saying. I'm saying sharing 3 elements between 2 rounds is stupid and should be forced out, as should facing the same team 3 rounds in a row.

[Manuel]

then why facing 2 teams 2 times in a row is an issue and facing 2 gens isn't?

every gen of every element is strong by default, while depending on the element u face twice it can even be easier for you, depending on the standing, is vault of the overall match up u have against that team

[dawn to dusk]

then why facing 2 teams 2 times in a row is an issue and facing 2 gens isn't?

every gen of every element is strong by default, while depending on the element u face twice it can even be easier for you, depending on the standing, is vault of the overall match up u have against that team

The problem was 3 teams 2 times in a row. 2 teams 2 times in a row was the solution, but 1 team 2 times in a row would be optimal

EDIT: 1 team 3 times in a row is bad too

[RavingRabbid]

Since we're out now and it doesn't affect me anymore.

I like the extra salvage on winning 3-0.
On the contrary I hate the extra discard on losing 3-0 and in particular 3-1 SO MUCH. That and the fact they are heavier than their salvage counterpart bonus. It just puts so much emphasis on not losing instead of winning.

[Wyand]

Since we're out now and it doesn't affect me anymore.

I like the extra salvage on winning 3-0.
On the contrary I hate the extra discard on losing 3-0 and in particular 3-1 SO MUCH. That and the fact they are heavier than their salvage counterpart bonus. It just puts so much emphasis on not losing instead of winning.

So true. I agree with all.

[RavingRabbid]

Also, for the vault doc, separate the deck discards from the vault discards by inputting them in two different cells maybe? It feels slightly tidier.

[iancudorinmarian]

Also, for the vault doc, separate the deck discards from the vault discards by inputting them in two different cells maybe? It feels slightly tidier.

Might be better having a generic cell for all vault discards combined and have just the deck discards cell for each deck.

[RavingRabbid]

Also, for the vault doc, separate the deck discards from the vault discards by inputting them in two different cells maybe? It feels slightly tidier.

Might be better having a generic cell for all vault discards combined and have just the deck discards cell for each deck.

That may also work but in the (fringe) case where you're vault discarding more than 60 cards there may be some issues.

[iancudorinmarian]

Also, for the vault doc, separate the deck discards from the vault discards by inputting them in two different cells maybe? It feels slightly tidier.

Might be better having a generic cell for all vault discards combined and have just the deck discards cell for each deck.

That may also work but in the (fringe) case where you're vault discarding more than 60 cards there may be some issues.

The rest could be added in the "penalties" cell, but I doubt that's ever going to happen. Unless we get some explosive mine EC...