War #11 - Suggestions and Feedback

[Zawadx]

War #11 - Suggestions and Feedback


Please post suggestions and feedback regarding War #11 in this thread for War #12's benefit.

[deuce22]

I like the concept of the new transmutation system, but I think it needs balancing. Can see my suggestion here.


Also, I've never been a fan of the market system. Prices were pretty unbalanced first 2 wars. And while I think the prices are overall improving, I think it is a system that will never be balanced. IMO, the biggest issue is that shards have been largely unrestricted. And while the market prices have been increased fairly significantly, this is going to have minimal effect on vault building and overall war meta.

The old system wasn't exactly balanced either. I think the vault building system needs a pretty sizeable overhaul that can actually have an impact on the meta, balance between elements, and overall strategy throughout war. I have an idea in my mind, but will take some time to actually formulate. Will try and post it at end of this war.

[Fippe94]

[17:59:45] ‹Fippe94› do you think that it could be a good idea in future work to lower amount of teams instead of members per team?
[17:59:55] ‹Fippe94› for example, skip teams which does not have a master

[TribalTrouble]

To build off Fippe's suggestion, you could group the elements into, say, 3-4 different groups. So you could have something like:

Team Brawny
Earth
Gravity
Life
Water

Team Brainy
Aether
Entropy
Light
Time

Team Bloody
Air
Darkness
Death
Fire

Purely an example. And some of the positions of names are arguable.

[Blacksmith]

Now when the auction is over I think it's time for evaluation.
These auction rules was a lot better than last year. Few people went to cheap or to expensive as a result of the rules. The only problem was that generals waited with their bidding which delayed the auction.

I have two suggestion. Remove the maximum amount of bids it only make people afraid of bidding early in the auction, since there's a chance they run out of choices like Dani did. Instead prevent Gens from having more than 5 winning bids at once in addition to other rules. That way there's really no big point in waiting with bids. The generals that did wait did not benefit from it imo?

The other suggestion is to simply increase the minimum raise timer from 5 to 10 or 20 points. That would certainly speed things up.

[MyNameIsJoey]

team light is still modded by zyardran. fixplz.

[kaempfer13]

with bids being allowed past the minimum players of the team I believe just bringing back locking of players (after 24 to 48 hours with no new bid on them) should work, so there is a good reason to bid early on players and continue to bid in a reasonable time.

also minor error in the vault sheet in cell S50: =if(or(S47>=V47,Z59,T48<50),"No","Yes") should be=if(or(S47>V47,Z59,T48<50),"No","Yes") otherwise you say that its illegal to spent exactly all points

also an error in z 49: =if(X49=Q$55, countif(R4:R20,">9"), countif(R4:R20,">9"))

 the first 9 should be 24. This only affects gravity directly

[kaempfer13]

Any chance this will be fixed? I told you what to do, now its just 60 clicks and 48 button presses.

[Zawadx]

with bids being allowed past the minimum players of the team I believe just bringing back locking of players (after 24 to 48 hours with no new bid on them) should work, so there is a good reason to bid early on players and continue to bid in a reasonable time.

also minor error in the vault sheet in cell S50: =if(or(S47>=V47,Z59,T48<50),"No","Yes") should be=if(or(S47>V47,Z59,T48<50),"No","Yes") otherwise you say that its illegal to spent exactly all points

also an error in z 49: =if(X49=Q$55, countif(R4:R20,">9"), countif(R4:R20,">9"))

 the first 9 should be 24. This only affects gravity directly

Fixed. Cheers.

[hainkarga]

So WMs ask for subs, I apply, WMs ask the generals for quarter of their vault to let me join.

MFW

[worldwideweb3]

So WMs ask for subs, I apply, WMs ask the generals for quarter of their vault to let me join.

MFW

They asked for 65~ cards?

[JonathanCrazyJ]

So WMs ask for subs, I apply, WMs ask the generals for quarter of their vault to let me join.

MFW

They asked for 65~ cards?

40