Which Rare Weapon Should I Pick as a Reward?

[Contrary]

I think it really depends on what kind of deck you want to go for. Titan, Druidic Staff, and Owl's Eye are immediately off the table because of how often AI3 drops them. Morning Star and Trident are off because they suck.

Fahrenheit is ok if you want to go for Firestall, but Fahrenheit are fairly common so it's not a big deal.
Eternity is good if you want to do some big rainbows or something, but I think those are mostly outdated. Eternity is a pretty good card on its own though and two can carry a deck. But on the other hand they aren't that uncommon from AI3
Discord is pretty good in speedbows, and are kind of uncommon.
Arsenic is great and pretty rare. Great addition to any kind of deck with death in it, Immobows included.
Vampire Stiletto is good with Crusader, in Mono Darks, and in Immobows. Kind of rare.
Lobos aren't very uncommon in AI3 and you can find lots in bronze. Good choice if you want to rush to RoL Hope.
Pulverizer is good in The Wrecking Ball and a few FG decks but I haven't had that much use for mine, aside from The Wrecking Ball (which is quite good). You can get a decent number from AI3.

So it all depends on what you want. Since I still only have one Arsenic I'd probably go back and get that rather than my Fahrenheit. My other choices would be Lobo and Stiletto.

[lorddoritos]

Pulverizer.

[Dragon Trainer]

Definitely Eternity. I accidentally chose fahrenheit-which stinks! And for my new deck I need an Eternity, which is near impossible to spin!

[ninjaclone09]

another good way to figure it out is to ask a more experienced player what rares he has. If he has a lot of one rare more than the others, that one is probably more common. If he has a lot less of one rare than the others, that one is probably more rare.  Also, never sell rares unless you have more than 12 of them (by then you'll be more experienced and know why)

Anyways, i have:
1 discord [entropy]
3 arsenic [death]
0 titans [gravity] (note: i have spun this in trainer)
1 pulverizer [earth] (note: i have never spun this before, i picked this weapon for the 500 score quest)
3 druidic staff [life]
1 fahrenheit [fire]
1 trident [water]
3 morning star [light]
1 owl's eye [air]
0 eternity [time] (note: i have spun this before on my old account)
1 vampire stiletto [darkness]
2 lobotomizer [aether]

[ashashin]

i have more lobotomizers than any other rare weapon, and i have least trident and then eternity
i picked eternity btw

[zhangvict]

Arsenic is great and pretty rare. Great addition to any kind of deck with death in it, Immobows included.

Arsenic is not rare! at lest not now. Many many poison decks that are currently in the bronze arena give you arsenic from normal spins.

Here are my rare weps , including both upped and unupped. I have never sold any rare cards except for upgraded morning glories:

3 Discord
12 Arsenic (10 unupped, 2 upped)
7 Titan (1 upped)
1 Pulverizer (from arena special spin, upped myself. I have never won this from ai3, but I hardly grinded ai3 anyway)
4 Jade/druidic staff (2 upped)
3 Fahrenheit
5 Trident
8 Morning star/glory (6 upped, all from Divine Glory/Paradox etc. I sold a lot, should have more than 6)
6 Owl's eye (1 upped from Neptune)
9 Eternity (2 upped from Lionheart)
3 Vampire Stilletto
9 Lobotomizer/Electrocutor (1 upped)

[Mathematistic]

Arsenic is great and pretty rare. Great addition to any kind of deck with death in it, Immobows included.

Arsenic is not rare! at lest not now. Many many poison decks that are currently in the bronze arena give you arsenic from normal spins.

But to get started with arena grinding, an arsenic in an antabow is crucial... It deals so much more damage than the hammer.

Consideration list (not in order):
Arsenic: A great addition to immonova/antabows. Gives a lot of advantages in pvp/arena/AI3
Vampire stiletto: Not a top choice, but facilitates nova-less immogolems pretty well. The upgraded version, vampire dagger, is almost as good as upgraded arsenic in rainbows.
Lobotomizer: RoL hope is still a pretty good FG grinder to get started with. Also makes dimensional shield decks more potent.
Pulverizer: Probably the best rare here. It is very useful in FGbows, while remaining crucial in SNbows in late game.

Top not-to-choose list (not in order):
Morning star:. *stares at Divine Glory*
Druidic staff: It is pretty easy to get it from AI3. 2 of the elders have it.
Trident: It may look good, but it's almost useless for every aspect. An earthquake does much better.

Others:
Fahrenheit: Not that impressive. But if you're making a -heavy deck for AI4 grinding, do consider a bit.
Discord: It mostly shines in arena and AI3. However, it's not very compatible with unupped farmers. This gem only shines in the veterans' pockets (who possesses a considerable amount of ).
Titan: Solid, powerful, straight-forward. As a steady source of damage output it might be OK. But still, it's not very compatible, even in upped decks unless you focus around it.
Eternity: Due to the fact that SGbow is outdated, it's less useful than pulverizer now... but it's OK in a ghostmare.
Owl's eye: Great CC, but not compatible in unupped grinders (again?!). However, in fun pvp rainbows it sees some use. Although octane has lots of these, it's not as bad as morning star... after all the CC is not bad.

[Olevar]

It depends on how much time you spend playing elements. If u play a lot and farm a lot, sooner or later u wil get all, but some of them shows less on spins. I found Arsenic, vampiric dagger and lobotomizer only rarely. If u play less, it is good to choose one of more playable weapons like pulverizer, eternity, owls eye eventualy arsenic or titan depends on preferble element..

[pulli23]

Arsenic is great and pretty rare. Great addition to any kind of deck with death in it, Immobows included.

Arsenic is not rare! at lest not now. Many many poison decks that are currently in the bronze arena give you arsenic from normal spins.

But to get started with arena grinding, an arsenic in an antabow is crucial... It deals so much more damage than the hammer.

Consideration list (not in order):
Arsenic: A great addition to immonova/antabows. Gives a lot of advantages in pvp/arena/AI3
Vampire stiletto: Not a top choice, but facilitates nova-less immogolems pretty well. The upgraded version, vampire dagger, is almost as good as upgraded arsenic in rainbows.
Lobotomizer: RoL hope is still a pretty good FG grinder to get started with. Also makes dimensional shield decks more potent.
Pulverizer: Probably the best rare here. It is very useful in FGbows, while remaining crucial in SNbows in late game.

Top not-to-choose list (not in order):
Morning star:. *stares at Divine Glory*
Druidic staff: It is pretty easy to get it from AI3. 2 of the elders have it.
Trident: It may look good, but it's almost useless for every aspect. An earthquake does much better.

Others:
Fahrenheit: Not that impressive. But if you're making a -heavy deck for AI4 grinding, do consider a bit.
Discord: It mostly shines in arena and AI3. However, it's not very compatible with unupped farmers. This gem only shines in the veterans' pockets (who possesses a considerable amount of ).
Titan: Solid, powerful, straight-forward. As a steady source of damage output it might be OK. But still, it's not very compatible, even in upped decks unless you focus around it.
Eternity: Due to the fact that SGbow is outdated, it's less useful than pulverizer now... but it's OK in a ghostmare.
Owl's eye: Great CC, but not compatible in unupped grinders (again?!). However, in fun pvp rainbows it sees some use. Although octane has lots of these, it's not as bad as morning star... after all the CC is not bad.

The first 3 weapons -especially lobotomizer & stilleto- are very, very easy to get from ai3. Eternity is difficult to get, as is morning glory - especially unupped: so I'd always get those. What is a good/bad deck for FG/arena farming should be a less important choice for the starter weapon; there's a good chance this "best" changes before one can actually buy the deck if you start out.

[furballdn]

Arsenic is great and pretty rare. Great addition to any kind of deck with death in it, Immobows included.

Arsenic is not rare! at lest not now. Many many poison decks that are currently in the bronze arena give you arsenic from normal spins.

But to get started with arena grinding, an arsenic in an antabow is crucial... It deals so much more damage than the hammer.

Consideration list (not in order):
Arsenic: A great addition to immonova/antabows. Gives a lot of advantages in pvp/arena/AI3
Vampire stiletto: Not a top choice, but facilitates nova-less immogolems pretty well. The upgraded version, vampire dagger, is almost as good as upgraded arsenic in rainbows.
Lobotomizer: RoL hope is still a pretty good FG grinder to get started with. Also makes dimensional shield decks more potent.
Pulverizer: Probably the best rare here. It is very useful in FGbows, while remaining crucial in SNbows in late game.

Top not-to-choose list (not in order):
Morning star:. *stares at Divine Glory*
Druidic staff: It is pretty easy to get it from AI3. 2 of the elders have it.
Trident: It may look good, but it's almost useless for every aspect. An earthquake does much better.

Others:
Fahrenheit: Not that impressive. But if you're making a -heavy deck for AI4 grinding, do consider a bit.
Discord: It mostly shines in arena and AI3. However, it's not very compatible with unupped farmers. This gem only shines in the veterans' pockets (who possesses a considerable amount of ).
Titan: Solid, powerful, straight-forward. As a steady source of damage output it might be OK. But still, it's not very compatible, even in upped decks unless you focus around it.
Eternity: Due to the fact that SGbow is outdated, it's less useful than pulverizer now... but it's OK in a ghostmare.
Owl's eye: Great CC, but not compatible in unupped grinders (again?!). However, in fun pvp rainbows it sees some use. Although octane has lots of these, it's not as bad as morning star... after all the CC is not bad.

The first 3 weapons -especially lobotomizer & stilleto- are very, very easy to get from ai3. Eternity is difficult to get, as is morning glory - especially unupped: so I'd always get those. What is a good/bad deck for FG/arena farming should be a less important choice for the starter weapon; there's a good chance this "best" changes before one can actually buy the deck if you start out.

Eternity can't be won from AI3 but that doesn't mean it's that rare. You'll get plenty of eternities and morning glories just by using oracle prediction each day.

[jmababab]

get weapon which is ur mark as simple as that my mark is aether so im geting lobotomizer

[jmababab]

I think it really depends on what kind of deck you want to go for. Titan, Druidic Staff, and Owl's Eye are immediately off the table because of how often AI3 drops them. Morning Star and Trident are off because they suck.

Fahrenheit is ok if you want to go for Firestall, but Fahrenheit are fairly common so it's not a big deal.
Eternity is good if you want to do some big rainbows or something, but I think those are mostly outdated. Eternity is a pretty good card on its own though and two can carry a deck. But on the other hand they aren't that uncommon from AI3
Discord is pretty good in speedbows, and are kind of uncommon.
Arsenic is great and pretty rare. Great addition to any kind of deck with death in it, Immobows included.
Vampire Stiletto is good with Crusader, in Mono Darks, and in Immobows. Kind of rare.
Lobos aren't very uncommon in AI3 and you can find lots in bronze. Good choice if you want to rush to RoL Hope.
Pulverizer is good in The Wrecking Ball and a few FG decks but I haven't had that much use for mine, aside from The Wrecking Ball (which is quite good). You can get a decent number from AI3.

So it all depends on what you want. Since I still only have one Arsenic I'd probably go back and get that rather than my Fahrenheit. My other choices would be Lobo and Stiletto.

discord is now common i got 3 of em already from spins