Which Rare Weapon Should I Pick as a Reward?

[TheOnlyNewb]

 I agree there's problems with ratings, as they are the opinion of only one player. Still grateful this exists for the people who don't know whether to choose a powerful weapon and change their deck or just a more useful one to their deck which fits in nicely. I had something else to say too, but i forgot it -_-

[eevee44]

thanx for the list

[TheForbiddenOracle]

On the first post, you can also win a MG from Dark Matter, though much less likely as only 2 copies in 104 card deck while Divine Glory has 6 glories in a 36 card deck

[Svenningen]

Imho, this should get reset.
I strongly advice for vampire dagger or arsenic, the two most seen in t50 decks, wich is where you go to farm required ones for FG's, as most decks use more than 1 rare wep.

[Jappert]

I agree with Sven, you pretty much always require multiple copies of a weapon in decent FG decks. So the first weapon to choose would be one to grind T50 with, while doing that you can easily get the other weapons needed.

Reset plx!

[plastiqe]

I have no access to the poll controls in this thread.

The guide is long overdue for an update as well.  I rewrote & reformatted the whole thing a little while ago except my internet crashed before I could submit it.

[Steppen_Wolf]

I picked Eternity, but does it really matter?

After some 90 matches (some 60 wins) I have 2 Lobotomizer, 2 Vampire Stiletto, 2 Eternity, 1 Owl's Eye and 2 Tridents.

These cards seem to be anything but rare.

[tttt]

When I was picking a rare from the quest I followed everyone's advice and picked an Eternity. Never used it. My FG farming decks have 2 pulvies most of the time. I advize picking a pulvy if you don't already have 2, otherwise eternity is decent choice.

[dragonsdemesne]

Voted for Eternity and Pulverizer, since I consider those to be by far the best ones, and apparently the community agrees with me, based on the poll at this time.  Pulverizer seems to be the hardest one to win for some reason, so it might be wiser to go with that, though Eternity is easier to play with, since it only needs one elements, not 2.

FWIW, I picked Druid Staff when I did the quest, because I was playing Monolife at the time.  It did alright, but when I wanted to make scaredgirl's rainbow deck, I was decking out a lot because I couldn't farm an eternity for a long time.  Plus, druid staffs are easier to farm; more AI decks use them.

[TheIdioticIdiot]

Voted for Eternity and Pulverizer, since I consider those to be by far the best ones, and apparently the community agrees with me, based on the poll at this time.  Pulverizer seems to be the hardest one to win for some reason, so it might be wiser to go with that, though Eternity is easier to play with, since it only needs one elements, not 2.

FWIW, I picked Druid Staff when I did the quest, because I was playing Monolife at the time.  It did alright, but when I wanted to make scaredgirl's rainbow deck, I was decking out a lot because I couldn't farm an eternity for a long time.  Plus, druid staffs are easier to farm; more AI decks use them.

actually, owl's eye, fahrenheit, arsenic, vamp stilleto, discord, and lobotomizer are used more in PvP
but since the game is heavily focused on FGs, where eternity and pulverizer really shine, they are best for newbies

[hopeatthetree]

I am building a  / deck and was wondering which rare i should pick?

[Hodari]

I am building a  / deck and was wondering which rare i should pick?

  If you intend for that to be your only deck for a while, obviously either vampire dagger or arsenic would be the ones to choose, though we'd need more information about the deck to say which.  Most likely though, unless the rest of the deck includes other poison as well, you'd be better off with the vampire dagger.

  On the other hand, pulverizer and eternity will probably be the most useful ones overall, so it may also be worth thinking ahead and not just basing it on the deck you are using now.   Also consider that you will only have ONE of the weapon you chose to start with, so you can't count on drawing it early in the game.  This would also suggest Eternity as it becomes more useful later in the game, either to prevent yourself from decking out or to rewind your opponent's larger creatures.  Of course once you get to a point where you can win against bronze league fairly often, you'll start getting other rares fairly quickly and this becomes less of a factor, but it may be worth considering when you're just getting started.