8th Trials - Phase 3 Community Vote [Water]

[Odii Odsen]

@treebeard xiii: I know you like water. How many wars did you play in team water so far? Do you think you have enough experience to lead a team with an element that had problems in past wars? What were the biggest problems in water in your opinion?

@ddevans: For some reason I always thought you are an ex master of water but I was wrong. Do you have experience with water in war? Do you think water has realistic chances to win war with the "current" war rules like the low amount of ups the teams can use?

@Blacksmith: I see the parallels you listed between Earth and Water. I was surprised though. I think playing/leading team water is much harder than team Earth, because Earth is more popular in war and you have options to get more experienced player. Why didn't you try one more time to go with Earth and afterwards with Water? Don't you think it was a bit too early to switch to a more "complicated" element? I know about your Skills but this is a challenge you'll need many time to offer. How active will you be in the next war? Any assumption?

For me ddevans and Blacksmith are in a tie at the moment. Treebeard is always a fair and loyal guy imo. I think tree needs one more war for war/water experience as Soldier or Lt. I know Blacksmith can lead a team but ddevans did the best job during phase 2. Like I said, tie at the moment here...

[TribalTrouble]

I agree that I'm not entirely sure which way to sway between those two.

[Laxadarap]

Realistically, do you think you can topple aether? Whats so new/not new this time (more important part)?

[Submachine]

Another War-related question series. Now about Propaganda! Yaay ^^

Question for ddevans96:

For me, you already proved that you can organize good propagandas.

Spoiler for propaganda gold:

However, some random fan of an opposing team was not lazy to criticize your work:

wow
such slime
transparent
so inedible
wow

What do you reply to this?

Question for treebeard xiii:

In the last war, I had some 'heavy donation' for the water tribe in the form of a possible propaganda mascot. By the time, Water already had a good propaganda, so I was late with my 'donation'. If you will be responsible for making Propaganda for Team Water in War #8, will you include my suggested mascot?

Spoiler for Hidden:

Seriously, will you?

Question for Blacksmith:

In the last war, when Team Earth still didn't have propaganda, I suggested a mascot for you, which was then rejected to do this:
http://elementscommunity.org/forum/propaganda/earth-51415/

Why? - is my question.

[ARTHANASIOS]

To all candidates:
 What is your opinion of Flooding? Overpowered/underpowered, overused/underused, overestimated/underestimated? Should it be buffed/nerfed/berfed? Can you make a shardless deck which can make an original use of 6 (yes, six) copies of this card?

[MyNameIsJoey]

MY question, part 2 : what if being able to walk on water removed your ability to swim.
You would have to choose between walking on water, or swimming around water.
What do you choose?

[Blacksmith]

All questions answered until now. 

To both my competitors.

You were both part of war team 7# last war. What is the reason for the result and what will you do different this time?

[hainkarga]

Watch this video and freely tell me what you think of this glorious man and his words: Be water my friend

[Espithel]

Dear all water triallists:

Water is an element I constantly underestimate and constantly glance over.
I've gone on record saying nymphs tears is the only good card in water. (And I regret it.)
Then I learn about the potency of ice shield, octopus, SoPa, and so much more. Stupid me.

But surely there has to be a reason for my ignorance.
So, other than flooding and abyss crawler, what is the weakest card in water's arsenal?
Why do you think this?

[Pineapple]

abyss crawler

I think you mean Blue Crawler. Abyss is pretty stronk.

[farscape]

Question to all candidates (challengers and old master too):

If I apply to participate in War, would you bid on me, and max how many cards ? 

[Espithel]

abyss crawler

I think you mean Blue Crawler. Abyss is pretty stronk.

Water is an element I constantly underestimate and constantly glance over.

Do you see what I mean? ;-;
I can't even remember which crawler is the bad one. Whyyy