My votes:
LIGHT: Definitely the steals. I'm also a fan of vampire stiletto in novabows, so one of those. After that... not sure. I'd say grab all the darkness stuff and then three whatevers.
FIRE: Sancs/miracles. I think we had to discard some sancs on one of the losses. (the one that wasn't mine :p)
AIR: All 5 time cards, and 2x fog shield, 2x flying weapon
AETHER: Yum. 1x explosion, 1x fractal, 5x novas, and probably two graboids.
ENTROPY: Bone walls and... I don't really care, maybe poisons?
WATER: 3x Purify for sure, then maybe 3x Freeze