mrpaper 2 (aether) Korugar 0 (earth)

[Boingo]

I hate to be that guy, but is the earth deck even legal?  Doesn't look like 50% earth to me.

Nope it's not legal.  That's my fault, as it was a rush job at the deadline - the place we were storing our decks/all threads crashed and wiped out all of our work for the round on the final day.  We had to reassemble it all from various other sources in order to post it up.

Anyway, if I'd noticed, I would've removed a wings and put in a stone pillar, in case you're curous.  It wouldn't have made any difference to the outcome.

But yeah, korugar posted/played the deck he was supposed to.  The illegal deck wasn't his fault.

That sucks.  I would have preferred a simple posting mistake as the penalty doesn't help us either way.

[Gocubbies1212]

I hate to be that guy, but is the earth deck even legal?  Doesn't look like 50% earth to me.

Nope it's not legal.  That's my fault, as it was a rush job at the deadline - the place we were storing our decks/all threads crashed and wiped out all of our work for the round on the final day.  We had to reassemble it all from various other sources in order to post it up.

Anyway, if I'd noticed, I would've removed a wings and put in a stone pillar, in case you're curous.  It wouldn't have made any difference to the outcome.

But yeah, korugar posted/played the deck he was supposed to.  The illegal deck wasn't his fault.

That sucks.  I would have preferred a simple posting mistake as the penalty doesn't help us either way.

can we still salvage from it?
by the way, great job mrpaper!

[coinich]

I hate to be that guy, but is the earth deck even legal?  Doesn't look like 50% earth to me.

Nope it's not legal.  That's my fault, as it was a rush job at the deadline - the place we were storing our decks/all threads crashed and wiped out all of our work for the round on the final day.  We had to reassemble it all from various other sources in order to post it up.

Anyway, if I'd noticed, I would've removed a wings and put in a stone pillar, in case you're curous.  It wouldn't have made any difference to the outcome.

But yeah, korugar posted/played the deck he was supposed to.  The illegal deck wasn't his fault.

Just as much my fault as it was yours; my job is to specifically check for this sort of thing.

[jmdt]

I hate to be that guy, but is the earth deck even legal?  Doesn't look like 50% earth to me.

Nope it's not legal.  That's my fault, as it was a rush job at the deadline - the place we were storing our decks/all threads crashed and wiped out all of our work for the round on the final day.  We had to reassemble it all from various other sources in order to post it up.

Anyway, if I'd noticed, I would've removed a wings and put in a stone pillar, in case you're curous.  It wouldn't have made any difference to the outcome.

But yeah, korugar posted/played the deck he was supposed to.  The illegal deck wasn't his fault.

That sucks.  I would have preferred a simple posting mistake as the penalty doesn't help us either way.

can we still salvage from it?
by the way, great job mrpaper!

If I understand right, you salvage from this deck since its the one posted and takes a penalty in addition to losing the match.  We'll have to consult with dd for the value of the penalty.

[TimerClock14]

I hate to be that guy, but is the earth deck even legal?  Doesn't look like 50% earth to me.

Nope it's not legal.  That's my fault, as it was a rush job at the deadline - the place we were storing our decks/all threads crashed and wiped out all of our work for the round on the final day.  We had to reassemble it all from various other sources in order to post it up.

Anyway, if I'd noticed, I would've removed a wings and put in a stone pillar, in case you're curous.  It wouldn't have made any difference to the outcome.

But yeah, korugar posted/played the deck he was supposed to.  The illegal deck wasn't his fault.

This was my fault too. I could have noticed and fixed this many times over whilst checking my own deck in the vault. 6 cards really sucks tho....

[ddevans96]

It's a 6 card penalty.