(Life Sideboard) Odii Odsen 3 - 0 MasterWalks (Gravity Lt.)

[Aves]

Technically there's still 6 hours or so on the clock, it's just that all the matches (besides this one) were played. I mean, technically this match was played too, we just don't have a 100% clear ruling atm.

[moehrpi]

In the overview thread discard is 6 and salvage is -6. Seems official.

[MasterWalks]

Alright Team Life and Team Gravity need a final answer from the War Masters on this asap. Right now, neither Team Life nor ourselves know if we discard, if we dont discard, if we rematch or what. This is very detrimental to both teams as we cannot accurately build decks without knowing if we discard. There is less than 24hours until deck building deadline and we still cant submit decks because we dont know what cards we still have.

the last thing we heard from any war master on this thread is this

Spoiler for Hidden:

To everyone angry at the decision, I apologize, and will try not to make decisions like this again.

My logic when talking to math about this was that both sides made honest mistakes. Life was rushed at the end and even I forgot the update to sideboard.
I think now that my ruling on Gravity was too soft. It was a simple mistake as well, but it can't be overlooked that this could have been avoided.

I messed up at my actions, and I'll offer a rematch with both teams using correct decks. If there's backlash against that, then I'll just give both teams discards.

I apologize again. PM WMs if there's any comments or complaints about this.

If we were supposed to rematch, neither Odii or myself knew. If we are supposed to discard, then we will be rushed into R2. Team Life and Team Gravity really need an answer and soon.

[InsignificantWeeaboo]

Alright Team Life and Team Gravity need a final answer from the War Masters on this asap. Right now, neither Team Life nor ourselves know if we discard, if we dont discard, if we rematch or what. This is very detrimental to both teams as we cannot accurately build decks without knowing if we discard. There is less than 24hours until deck building deadline and we still cant submit decks because we dont know what cards we still have.

the last thing we heard from any war master on this thread is this

Spoiler for Hidden:

To everyone angry at the decision, I apologize, and will try not to make decisions like this again.

My logic when talking to math about this was that both sides made honest mistakes. Life was rushed at the end and even I forgot the update to sideboard.
I think now that my ruling on Gravity was too soft. It was a simple mistake as well, but it can't be overlooked that this could have been avoided.

I messed up at my actions, and I'll offer a rematch with both teams using correct decks. If there's backlash against that, then I'll just give both teams discards.

I apologize again. PM WMs if there's any comments or complaints about this.

If we were supposed to rematch, neither Odii or myself knew. If we are supposed to discard, then we will be rushed into R2. Team Life and Team Gravity really need an answer and soon.

I actually asked mathman about this. He said both teams will discard from whatever deck they used.

[worldwideweb3]

In the overview thread discard is 6 and salvage is -6. Seems official.

yh, this makes it clear...
http://elementscommunity.org/forum/round-1-246/war-12-round-1-results-countdown/

Though i guess wms could've still posted here too.