Yaladilae, just because you believe ntz's deck is bad (to which I agree), he or she is inexperienced on the forums and has insulted a good deck, and is not providing good statistics to back their deck (most likely due to inexperience), it does not give you any right to act haughty and lord your experience and history of good/reputable decks over him/her. Nor does it give you (or anyone else) any right to take ntz out of context.
aether mono gives you very good chance (80-90%) against FGs, which don't molest a permanents.
I'm not too experienced in elements myself, but I do believe aether mono would give you a good chance against FG's that don't bother your permanents (hold phase dragons until you can kill miracle, can kill FQ, destiny, paradox, ferox...). Perhaps not 80-90 if it decks out as xdude said, but that's certainly not a claim deserving of such an insult as "please classify this in the humor category/deck help, not deck-building." This is a deck, its meant to tackle false gods, it may not be as good as others/yours but ntz has every right to post it and defend it. And what gives you the right to determine whether or not a deck should go into deck help? Every deck posted here, and many which are inefficient or have low win rates, could use help/insight and do receive help/insight in this forum, including your own.
I'm not saying your points are not valid (most of them are), nor am I condoning ntz's inexperienced arrogance to condemn SG's deck (a deck which I used and still respect), but the way you present your arguments and yourself is rude and bullying. Yes, you have made good decks/have live account testing/have different FG decks and yes you can probably kick my ass in PvP, but that experience does not give you the right to be so condescending.
First, let me clear myself
I am not acting haughty or anything
A person can be inexperience, but can a person come in with a tone acting offensive to another person and posting something that has no backed evidence and then lying about it?
If he came in with a postive tone, I would not sound like that
Besides I was not mostly pointing to him, for there is some other guy who just responded "Yea, right" when I try to make a solid statement over something thats true
No one ever wants to take him out of context, nor does anyone ever wanted to, and now you have suggesteed it...
I am not saying anything in offense when i suggest this goes to deck help. This deck clearly needs a) alot of work on b) cannot claim such a high precentage
If he post a deck here to generate postive discussion, no problem, I will give you a feedback nicely, like I do with the rest of the community
But posting something and the opening sentense is XXXX's deck crap, here is mine. Does that open any postive discussion point or even an attitude in which I can do anything but feel disgusted about?
Seriously, think again, look around, how many people did I help in this community and apologise if i was ever rude and feel i own them an apology? If he came in saying I have put together this this deck, i think its very good FG, prehaps even claiming a high win rate, then I would NEVER be rude like that
Last point, I probably cant kick your ass at pvp, I am not experienced in that. And for someone like me, if i suck, i own up. And i wont go posting decks and say, this is the best pvp deck, much better then XXXX's, his deck is crap.
Now if you read that far and still think i SUCK, its ok. I just want to ask you 1 thing
In the aether thread, he claims (claimed) he makes around 20k a day with that deck, but then his deck is mostly un-upped? That seems to be a little fishy, not just the figure, but the way he spent the electum.
Once again, i just want to say, if you are inexperience, no problem, I am too and i accept this. If you are lying and abusing others, I gave no tolerance. If you still want to call me a bully go ahead? I am ashamed... of you
On a side note, if you want a more detail feedback explaining why mono aether is not as good, I can say more, but Icy might be the best person to ask.
Peace
