Elements PvP Tournament - Suggestions and Feedback

[Jen-i]

nope - but it has happened before

[ddevans96]

Vineroz doesn't have a functioning computer right now and my real life is incredibly stressful at the moment. Something will be up in the next few hours. Sorry for the delay.

[Jen-i]

No worries and thank you for your time and attention - it is appreciated

[dragonsdemesne]

It'll probably end up being either some sort of speedbuilding, or recycling an already used successful idea.

[zer0 tolerance]

I hope the tournament is posted soon... want time to get a good deck going.

[dawn to dusk]

dunsies, cant really get building though...

[Scaramanga]

Suggestion:

Unupgraded tournament, no shards

Only creature allowed: Fate Egg

Ban: All CC (exept pandemonium), dmg dealing spells (such as Fire bolt, Nightmare etc) and all weaponds.

[Submachine]

Suggestion:

Tournament Organizers review the ideas in the "Your ideas!" section once a week and comment on ideas whether they should make good or bad tournaments or how balanced they are. If TOs have authority to overwrite comments, they should comment "good enough", "plausible idea" or "not accepted" under the ideas (and even put not accepted or already done ideas in spoilers). This way it should be reviewed easier.

I suggest this because it is good to know whether our ideas are OK or just take the place from other good ideas.

[Vineroz]

Spoiler for Hidden:

Suggestion:

Tournament Organizers review the ideas in the "Your ideas!" section once a week and comment on ideas whether they should make good or bad tournaments or how balanced they are. If TOs have authority to overwrite comments, they should comment "good enough", "plausible idea" or "not accepted" under the ideas (and even put not accepted or already done ideas in spoilers). This way it should be reviewed easier.

I suggest this because it is good to know whether our ideas are OK or just take the place from other good ideas.

Besides the fact that this is a massive work going through hundreds of posts, the review itself is hard to construct. There are no unified guideline to define an idea as "accepted" or "possible with tweaks". Many ideas we had were inspired by some possibly very bad ideas. Sometimes we just look at an idea and come up with something mostly different.

That being said, it could be doable if any one of us has some extra free time.

[Submachine]

Will all tournaments be posted on wednesday nights or after? :/

[Calindu]

Will all tournaments be posted on wednesday nights or after? :/

I have already spoken with you about this, but let's do it again?

I and dd both live in opposite timezones, it's hard to find eachother in chat and setting up a tournament often needs 1 hour or more for balance issues, wordings, etc., which have to be all discussed.

Also we have our own lifes, you can't expect us to simply post the tournaments 1 hour after the one before has finished.

Please consider that if we post the tournaments on wednesday night, you have more than 2 days to prepare. That's not enough? Considering that a tournament takes 2 hours to 3 most of the time, I think that's more than enough.

[Submachine]

Okay, I'm complaining too much.