Hmmm, a touchy subject. What's wrong with it? Well, mostly that it's not meant to be. Sorry to make this conversation more akward, but two males cannot reproduce. Also, I believe it is morally wrong to lust after another man.
A)
So your argument is
1) Two males cannot reproduce.
2) Sex that cannot result in reproduction is not meant to be
3=1+2) It's not meant to be
go to B
B)
As has been pointed out above Sterile Heterosexuals cannot reproduce
1) Sterile heterosexual couples cannot reproduce.
2) Sex that cannot result in reproduction is not meant to be
3=1+2) It's not meant to be
(If you find this conclusion to be false go to C. If you find it to be true go to E.)
C)
A common response to the conclusion of B is to go with a softer claim for premise 2
1) Homosexual sex is not the kind of sex that has a chance to reproduce
2) Sex that is not of the kind of sex that has a chance to reproduce is not meant to be
3) Sterile Heterosexual sex is a form of Heterosexual sex
4) Heterosexual sex is the kind of sex that has a chance to reproduce
5=1+2) Homosexual sex is not meant to be
6=3+4) Sterile Heterosexual sex is a form of the kind of sex that has a chance to reproduce
7=2+6) Sterile Heterosexual sex is meant to be
go to D
D)
Sterile sex is a different kind of sex than non sterile sex
1) Sterile sex is not the kind of sex that has a chance to reproduce
2) Sex that is not of the kind of sex that has a chance to reproduce is not meant to be
3) Homosexual non sterile sex is a form of non sterile sex
4) Non sterile sex is the kind of sex that has a chance to reproduce
5=1+2) Sterile sex is not meant to be
6=3+4) Homosexual non sterile sex is a form of the kind of sex that has a chance to reproduce
7=2+6) Homosexual non sterile sex is meant to be
E)
Condoms reduce the chance of reproduction to negligible but still existent levels
1) Safe sex has a low-none chance of reproduction.
2) Sex that cannot result in reproduction is not meant to be
3=1+2) It's not meant to be
(If you find this conclusion to be false go to C and replace sterile with safe. If you find it to be true go to F.)
F) Congratulations! Your belief of non-recreational reproduction are consistent. However most will not share your view that recreational sex is immoral.