New pillars art poll - reloaded

[nilsieboy]

the old ones are better

[ddevans96]

All the third ones, because we kind of do need a change.

However, my favorite idea is that we should take the current pillars, make them more detailed and realistic, and put a background defining that element, so they look cooler, but we still have a theme. But that's just me

[Lucifear]

Again, I love every new pillar released! It's all beautiful!
Except for the Earth pillar.
I use earth constantly, and would hate to see it changed like that...It's almost...Cartoonish.
Of course, the opinion of one is not the fact of the majority
Great works as always zanz!

[kobisjeruk]

i MSPAINT'd stone pillar with the first example in my previous post and i think it look a lot better (albeit with a few adjustment, its too dark as it is)

(http://imageplay.net/img/m7Gbd75390/stones.bmp)

[kalkiran]

the pillars still arent as good as the other ones for all the other elements-theyre great and asthetic but they still dont have the right feel. still great works zanz!

[vrt]

I still had my old aether one laying around, just thought I'd throw it into the mix:







There, now for another 3 months of idling!



EDIT: Also, zanz, could you change that link to http://www.vrt-designs.com?

[edunavas]

All the third ones, because we kind of do need a change.

However, my favorite idea is that we should take the current pillars, make them more detailed and realistic, and put a background defining that element, so they look cooler, but we still have a theme. But that's just me

By the way, i think all (older) cards art should be revised, making then more detailed and realistic using the same picture.

[Dragoon]

I still had my old aether one laying around, just thought I'd throw it into the mix:

I love it!  Awesome art vrt.  (lol, art, vrt.)

[Wisemage]

i voted 2, 2, 2, 3

might be willing to accept the third art for life, but i like the second one better.

[Xinef]

Earth definitely needs something better, I like the stone henge art by kobisjeruk much better than 2 or 3.

Life 2 was quite good actually, but the background from 3 is outstanding... definitely 3 looks perfect, but the pillar from 2 with 3's background would also look great.

As for fire, adding the 'torch-tower' thingy definitely helped, but I have to agree that the marks should be replaced or removed. The fire from 1 looks quite good still... I guess it could be used if only the background was replaced.

As for aether, I quite like the 3-rd one, but vrt's art is also good. Aether is quite a hard element to imagine so I guess that might be problematic, but I personally like the way it looks right now.

[Chatix]

Fire 3 is messed up,
I think,
because none of the other pillars have their mark in the image of their pillar,
so why this one?
And it just looks messed up,
sorry zanz for the hard judgement, but it's what I think.

[Essence]

I'd like to see Fire1 with the background from fire2 or fire3.