New pillars art poll - reloaded

[zanzarino]

According to the results from the previous poll (if anyone can lock that one please do) the stone pillar did not have a massive/stone feeling and life, fire and aether did lack a perspective/pillar feeling.

I tried to improve those four and we now have an extra option, please keep voting and commenting.

A final poll for the quantum pillar will come when I'll have the art for it.

[Retribution]

Sweet, new art!
And first post!

I love the 3 new ones, except the aether one looks...barely changed, just gave it some pillar forme...it's better than it originally was, though 

[linkcat]

The old pillars are still way better than the new ones.

[twinsbuster]

The old pillars are still way better than the new ones.

yes
I only vote life 3 but not other
because of the background
just like other successful art in the previous poll

[Amilir]

The new emerald looks GREAT.
Aether looks good.
Earth looks like you squashed the image it's based on, and not very good anyway.
Fire looks much better, still a bit meh.

[Glitch]

I laughed.
I cried.
I lost 15 pounds.
This is the best new pillar art I've ever seen.
-Barack Obama

[mogv]

The only problem I find is the fire pillar. You used the art from the second one and added a pillar which is fine but I personally dont like the fact that the bottom left part of the image is sticking outside the pillar. I would prefer for fire to just be coming out instead.
Props to all the new art though.

[Kuroaitou]

You keep on outdoing yourself Zanz.

On that note, the ones for and have been MASSIVELY improved (the 3 'prongs' of were simple enough to get the job done, while the forest background for is, to me, beautiful). 2 still looked like a pillar to me, so I'm unsure about which one to vote for. >.> (Although the 3rd one being up in the 'clouds' was a nice touch).

The only one that I don't love is 3 - the marks are kind of annoying to look at, considering we already have images of the mark everywhere. If you removed those marks and simply made them to be 'glowing embers', the image would be near perfect, but I feel those 'bubbles' aren't doing the art justice. The 'cone' you've added to control the flame (as if it was a torch) was genius - the marks detract away from the column of fire in that sense.

Otherwise, I'll vote later when I hear everyone else's opinions. Thanks again Zanz.

[jmizzle7]

I agree about the Fire Pillar. The marks probably shouldn't be there, as they were distracting me from the rest of the pillar art. Like little flies

[Kuroaitou]

I agree about the Fire Pillar. The marks probably shouldn't be there, as they were distracting me from the rest of the pillar art. Like little flies

Oh, you and your silly puns.

But I suppose I'll still vote for all the newer card art #3 pieces now that I think about it. (I still feel guilty though...)

[Bloodshadow]

I agree. Get rid of the Fire Marks in Fire 3. Otherwise, they all look awesome.

[twinsbuster]

You keep on outdoing yourself Zanz.

you are too busy and should ask someone else to help you on the art.

Don't try to do everything by yourself. Take care~