Rate the song above you

[mesaprotector]

7/10

I will say it's unlike anything I've heard before. I do like it, but the repetition is sometimes a bit too much. Will definitely check out more stuff in this genre though.

[Aves]

 9.5/10.
This. Is. Amazing. A bit mellow, but mellow is good.

[Uppercut]

7/10, I like what is happening tonally but the composition feels too short and the build ups feel a bit abrupt. This does in 2:20 what should've taken twice that amount of time and suffers for it.

[DrunkDestroyer]

I felt like it started very well, for lack of any musical terms/knowledge I liked the slow building up of the instruments/sounds, especially once I started hearing the familiar ish guitar sound, it felt very much like a clever mix of the ambient epic sounds I used to like, and some of the more guitar based stuff I listen to now. When the vocals started up, I quickly realised that it wasn't the kind of stuff I liked, which for me, was a shame. From that point, it had a few moments where it seemed to be going well, but those kinds of vocals really get to me, and by the end just annoyed me to be honest.

6/10 for me, but that call is just due to a difference in taste to be honest.

I used to like it just as an opener, but the more I listen to it, the more I like it as a song, want to see what others think 

[johannhowitzer]

8/10, very nice sound.  Could use a little more creativity in the guitar part (something besides block chords), but the simpler texture serves it well enough, and it's not an "oh baby baby I love you" dime a dozen song.

&feature=related

[Uppercut]

This is a hard one for me because I'm not exactly a pop kind of guy, but on the other hand this is objectively well crafted and well played. If I had to rate Regina on her merits I'd give this a 10/10, if I were to rate it on the likeliness of me listening to this again maybe a 5/10. I like it, but it isn't something I'd find myself in the mood for very often.

[bucky1andonly]

I didn't really like that one, but the sound is something I thought I would like and listened to other songs on that album which I did enjoy a lot more.  8/10 because it lead me to songs I liked.

[Aves]

3/10
I can see why some would enjoy that song. I did not enjoy it.

[mesaprotector]

7/10

Not bad, but maybe I'd like it more if I listened to it again in a few days. (The pan flute that came in about halfway through was my favorite part.)

[bucky1andonly]

Now I am all for symphonies, but when something exciting is happening.  Pretty sure I've heard that before mesa, but 9/10.  And first comment is the best ever.

I brushed my teeth to this song once. Most epic moment of my life.

Really, you gave Foo Fighters 3/10 for such an epic song.  I'd like a second opinion.

In Your Honor (

)

then from the 2nd cd of that album

Razor (

&feature=related)

[mesaprotector]

6/10 for both

Not really the sort of music I tend to like, but enjoyable enough. The first song began well.

Also, can we stop complaining when someone has different taste? I won't complain if this is given a 1. Seriously.

[johannhowitzer]

9/10 - not one of my favorites, but as usual with Pink Floyd, very well written and executed.  An undeniable classic, with a strong meaning underneath - whether you agree with it or not.

(I would like to take a moment to thank Uppercut for starting what has become one of my favorite topics from any forum ever.  I've encountered some new things I like here, too!)