2016 Guild Championships - Discussion

[Solaris]

For what it's worth, i see Guilds as encompassing all aspects of the forum, both PvP and Non-Pvp.

I feel a Guild Championships should reflect that. Some people prefer PvP, some prefer Non-Pvp, I think it should have both

EDIT: but I'm not too fussed either way, just my 2 cents

Tending to agree. Perhaps more PvP than Non-PvP?

[Ginyu]

I prefer combining both PvP and non-PvP, a once-per-year Guild Championship should be more than an ordinary team-PvP-event. Looking back at Guild quests, there was a lot of non-pvp-content, and I liked that as a unique thing of Guilds.

[UTAlan]

I also prefer having at least *some* non-PvP involved.

[iancudorinmarian]

Maybe add a poll?

[mathman101]

I also prefer having at least *some* non-PvP involved.

+1 for this. I too would like to have at least a bit of both non-pvp and pvp.

[Zawadx]

Maybe add a poll?

I don't see the need, as people from each guild appreciate non-pvp. Non-pvp and co-operation is a big part of guilds, and I would like to preserve them in these championships.

My plan right now is to have two primary events with 3 heats each (one pvp, other non-pvp) to decide final seeding for the championships (these events will count for next season, and also have more weight?) while final championships will be pvp but with non-pvp 'support'.

[RootRanger]

A majority of players want some form of non-pvp, but is there any specific form of non-pvp still supported by a majority? In other words, some people might be thinking of puzzles when they imagine the kind of non-pvp they want to see, while others are thinking of subjective design tasks. Both groups agree that they want non-pvp, but not on the type of non-pvp. It's not that simple.

[Zawadx]

A majority of players want some form of non-pvp, but is there any specific form of non-pvp still supported by a majority? In other words, some people might be thinking of puzzles when they imagine the kind of non-pvp they want to see, while others are thinking of subjective design tasks. Both groups agree that they want non-pvp, but not on the type of non-pvp. It's not that simple.

Good point. I've added two polls, one for non-pvp in general and another for their role in supporting matches. Please vote to state your opinion!