1033
Religion / Re: Responses to a few common arguments
« on: August 04, 2010, 09:12:21 pm »Quote from: Morpheus
How do you define real? If real is what you can feel, smell, taste and see, then 'real' is simply electrical signals interpreted by your brainThat is my perception of reality, yes. I could be living in the Matrix, or dreaming all of reality, but regardless there are rules by which this reality is governed and I don't expect the Earth to stop spinning or for giant mutant ants to start reaking havoc. If you allow for a god to be causing footsteps next to you, why do you not allow for gremlins to be hacking the electrical grid or fairies causing deer to run in front of your car? Or do you also believe in those things, as well? I sincerely do not see a difference between the two.
because if I begin discounting my own perceptions of the world, then I have no basis whatsoever left by which to make decisions. Heck, I can't even tell if I am making decisions at that point.Of course you can discount your perceptions and continue to function, make decisions, and live your life. You just have to put it in perspective.
You see a pencil in a glass full of water and the pencil appears broken, you pull it out and it appears straight and whole. You don't think "my eyes have deceived me and I can no longer trust them for gathering data." Your understanding of physics allows you to comprehend what is happening and adjust your conception accordingly.
It's the same if I lose my keys in my apartment, I don't think "some mysterious force has entered my abode and stolen or hidden my keys." I realize my memory is fallible and then I use a logical approach to finding my keys.
You all may have already seen this video or something similar, but I find it very thought-provoking: