1
Game Suggestions and Feedback / Re: Rainbow Mark- the 13th element
« on: August 19, 2010, 10:35:30 pm »
Hrm."Takes away from the entire flavor".... I haven't yet seen a player who thought that adding an "other" mark would destabilize and destroy the game fundamentals. Can I have some more hyperbole, plox?
It seems to me that regulars have a very different understanding of the game Elements. I guess this is understandable, as the forums help create and emphasize the "Elements" part of the game, with Elemental wars and Masters of Elements and such. Apparently there's a backstory; I've never noticed the existence of such, although I play often.
As it is, the game taken by itself is devoid of almost any such connotation, except for the name of the game. As it stands now, there is little real "theme" that would be broken by having an "other" element. Maybe if you added stronger story/content to go along with the theme - pretty it up, as it were - then jmiz's point against "Other" would make sense for everybody, not just forum regulars. But for now, there is nothing in-game that makes "other" an unnatural aberration, it seems to me.
Or perhaps my opinion is moot, as I'm not a forum regular and this game is made around forum regulars, not the other peeps who play it.
It seems to me that regulars have a very different understanding of the game Elements. I guess this is understandable, as the forums help create and emphasize the "Elements" part of the game, with Elemental wars and Masters of Elements and such. Apparently there's a backstory; I've never noticed the existence of such, although I play often.
As it is, the game taken by itself is devoid of almost any such connotation, except for the name of the game. As it stands now, there is little real "theme" that would be broken by having an "other" element. Maybe if you added stronger story/content to go along with the theme - pretty it up, as it were - then jmiz's point against "Other" would make sense for everybody, not just forum regulars. But for now, there is nothing in-game that makes "other" an unnatural aberration, it seems to me.
Or perhaps my opinion is moot, as I'm not a forum regular and this game is made around forum regulars, not the other peeps who play it.