Element breakdownThought it would help if we made a list of effect-specific counters per element.
Strategy - Counter(s)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6bce6/6bce6416d1b3994142b209e6e368a63cf9be6a3c" alt="Aether :aether"
Immortals/Quintessence - Shield
Lightning - Bigger creatures, Quintessence
PU - Quintessence, CC
Phase Shield - Momentum, PC, Bolts
Lobotomizer - Quintessence, no removable skills
Mindgate - PC, pendulum heavy
Quint Fireeaters, Titanbow
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/25d82/25d826a75dabb18288f7c4f300de18543cec2ceb" alt="Air :air"
OE - Quintessence, PC, CC, large creatures
Shockwave - Quintessence, large creatures
Wings - Momentum, PC, flying creatures
Unstable Gas - PC, reflective shield,
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6f20f/6f20fdc5d87bd18a3bdab6114dd6571d926d26ed" alt="Fire :fire"
denial
Flying Weapon - RT, CC, Lobotomize
Titanbow, Cat Titan
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/887ff/887ff885f0991162423674dd57e756dac5ebc764" alt="Darkness :darkness"
Steal - Enchant Artifact, limited permanent use
Devourer - Sanctuary, CC (holy light could be preferred if they don't use lycans), lower QI
Vampire effect - Antimatter, Lobotomize
Drain Life - Reflective shield, Discord, denial, Quintessence
Nightmare - Sanctuary
Nightfall - PC, Gravity Shield (dragons)
Liquid Shadow - Quintessence, no skills, big/powerful creatures
Voodoo Doll - RT,
No Devtal For You, Antimatter Stall
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/da878/da878cc340bc8cf11e73727d0138a3a8d9296249" alt="Death :death"
Plague - Quintessence
Bonewall - Mitosis, Fractal, Momentum, Adrenaline
Skull Shield - Momentum, large creatures, PC
Graveyard - CC (plenty), PC
Poison/Venom - Purify, CC, PC, Lobotomize
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc932/cc9326bb4fbdbace74cb061abfe0a36c8eebd9b1" alt="Earth :earth"
Earthquake - Pillarless, Enchant Artifact
Pulverizer - Limited permanent use, Enchant Artifact
Titanium Shield - Momentum, attack buffs, PC
Gaurd - Quintessence, CC
Shrieker Rush - Lots of CC
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/45d25/45d258c264a6038b397f3871010b7b0fa83555e3" alt="Entropy :entropy"
CC - Quintessence, CC (nymph, elf)
Dissipation Shield - PC, Momentum, lots of damage
Discord - Sanctuary, low QI, rainbow dip
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6f20f/6f20fdc5d87bd18a3bdab6114dd6571d926d26ed" alt="Fire :fire"
CC - Quintessence, big creatures
PC - Limited permanent use, Enchant Artifact
Firebolts - Reflective shield, denial
Low HP/ high attack creatures - Decent CC, damage shield, Paradox, Antimatter
Fahrenheit - PC, denial
Fire Shield - PC, Momentum, big creatures
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ecb75/ecb75979713e036e2ffb17f1e6b1caf929ce0e9b" alt="Gravity :gravity"
I guess this is where we list our own weaknesses... *shrugs* Why not?
Momentum - Lobotomize
Gravity Shield - PC, small creatures
Gravity Pull - Quintessence
Black Hole - Monos and Duos, Sanctuary
Acceleration - Lobotomize
Catapult - PC, Quintessence
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a0fb7/a0fb78ed34d3269c8a733136e4a7c02b9e732fb9" alt="Life :life"
Mitosis - CC, Lobotomize
Thorn Carapace - Momentum, PC
Adrenaline - Infection, damage shield
Scorpion - Lobotomize, Shield, CC
Emerald Shield - No bolts, Momentum, more attack
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9ab6f/9ab6ff8c9b974f26881abd5b3dc883e3aacc3f38" alt="Light :light"
Sanctuary - PC
Miracle - Earthquake
Hope - Momentum, mass CC
Crusader - CC, Enchanted weapons, no weapons, Lobotomize
Luciferine - Lobotomize, CC
Morning Star - Freeze + Shockwave, damage shield
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b03f9/b03f99ea8c3c39ed8bb22cd70b5e708ab4fe4881" alt="Time :time"
RT - Quintessence, cheap creature rush, PC (Eternity)
Neurotoxin - Purify
Hasten - PC
Pharaoh - Lobotomize, lots of CC (Scarab gen.), Gravity Shield, Quintessence
Ghost of the Past - Sanctuary (Nightmare), CC
Anubis - Strong CC, damage shield
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6cb25/6cb25c56ede1975dcd80ce7fe52bb1f0e872acc4" alt="Water :water"
Purify - No poisons
Trident - PC, Enchant Artifact
Freeze - Quintessence, CC (squid)
Ice Shield - Momentum, PC
Toadfish - Quintessence, CC
Nymph Tears - CC, non-water-pillar control
Ice Bolt - Reflective shield,