Surprisingly I'm the first one to say Otyugh, especially the upped one.
This is the case, because I really like decks with creature-spamming, namely Pestal (my favourite deck), Rol/Hope, or recently a deck featuring Rustlers and mitosified Cockatrices (there are some others as well, but these are the ones I use most frequently).
A single early Otyugh can annoy any of these three like hell, which makes it pretty important to get Eclipses or Electrocuters out to counter it, while the poor Rustler deck can only try and outrush the opponent.
Edit: Ah, wait, furballdn allready had it in his long list, I failed to read as a whole. But still, I'm the first one to mention Otyugh as my
single most hated card
![Wink ;)](https://elementscommunity.org/forum/Smileys/solosmileys/wink.gif)