Royal Rumble - What's da Uberest Creature in da Game

[Exiili]

Easy choices.

sapphire charger => My favourite creature. Easy to play, hard to kill and go through shields.
Lava golems => Pack a big punch right at the beginning and only get bigger.
Forest spirit => Same as golem, but a tad slower.
Dune scorpions => Neurotoxin is very awesome.
Graboid => 4 mana to get a shieker? I'll take that.

Edit: Also my first post.

[evima]

My choices:

Purple Nymph: instantly "kills" an attack-based creature,
getting healing for you at the same time, as many time as you want...
Deserves to be called ultimate, no?

Otyugh: another instant killer, this time not with healing,
but he has potential to literally "kill" every single non-immortal creature.

Graboid: I believe there was a mistake in inputting his stats.

Lava Golem: he's designed to be strong other than HP of 1,
but that weakness is easily compensated by a Quint.

Fallen Elf: Elements is fun, partly because of weird creatures created by him.
Not only funny, that can be used either as a buff or as a nerf.

By the way, the top 10 so far (98 members voted) are:

53 Graboid
46 Phoenix
41 Lava Golem
40 Otyugh
21 Purple Nymph
-------------------
17 Fallen Elf
17 Crusader
17 Dune Scorpion
15 Horned Frog
12 Devourer

Want to see more? (<EDIT> Errors fixed)

(11th ~ 18th)
09 Amber Nymph
09 Blue Nymph (<EDIT> This was missing)
08 Sapphire Charger
08 Steam Machine
07 Arctic Squid
--------------------
06 Photon
06 Phase Dragon
05 Forest Spirit

-- Average: 5.04 --

04: (4 creatures, 19th ~ 22nd)
Maxwell's Demon / Green Nymph / Pegasus / Firefly Queen

03: (6 creatures, 23rd ~ 28th)
Virus / Skeleton / Graviton Mercenary / Shrieker /
Iridium Warden / Spark

02: (16 creatures, 29th ~ 44th, median)
Flesh Spider / Hematite Golem / Crimson Dragon / Red Nymph /
Toadfish / Mind Flayer / Nymph Queen / Firefly /
Fate Egg / Anubis / Pharaoh / Ghost of the Past /
Golden Nymph / Parasite / Minor Vampire / Black Nymph

01: (25 creatures, 45th ~ 69th)
Abomination / Purple Dragon / Vulture / Mummy /
Deathstalker / Grey Nymph / Armagio / Colossal Dragon /
Chimera / Antlion / Stone Dragon / Auburn Nymph /
Forest Scorpion / Chrysaora / Blue Crawler / Golden Dragon /
Guardian Angel / Light Nymph / Dragonfly / Deja Vu /
Black Dragon / Gargoyle / Immortal / Turquoise Nymph /
Voodoo Doll

00: (16 creatures, 70th ~ 85th)
Lycanthrope / Schrödinger's Cat / Bone Dragon / Graviton Fire Eater /
Gnome Rider / Emerald Dragon / Rustler / Cockatrice /
Ash Eater / Fire Spirit / Ice Dragon / Wyrm /
Azure Dragon / Devonian Dragon / Scarab / Phase Spider

I enjoyed making this.

[jmdt]

My choices:

Purple Nymph: instantly "kills" an attack-based creature,
getting healing for you at the same time, as many time as you want...
Deserves to be called ultimate, no?

Otyugh: another instant killer, this time not with healing,
but he has potential to literally "kill" every single non-immortal creature.

Graboid: I believe there was a mistake in inputting his stats.

Lava Golem: he's designed to be strong other than HP of 1,
but that weakness is easily compensated by a Quint.

Fallen Elf: Elements is fun, partly because of weird creatures created by him.
Not only funny, that can be used either as a buff or as a nerf.

By the way, the top 10 so far (98 members voted) are:

53 Graboid
46 Phoenix
41 Lava Golem
40 Otyugh
21 Purple Nymph
-------------------
17 Fallen Elf
17 Crusader
17 Dune Scorpion
15 Horned Frog
12 Devourer

Want to see more?

(11th ~ 17th)
09 Amber Nymph
08 Sapphire Charger
08 Steam Machine
07 Arctic Squid
06 Photon
-------------------
06 Phase Dragon
05 Forest Spirit

-- Average: 4.99 --

04: (4 creatures, 18th ~ 21st)
Maxwell's Demon / Green Nymph / Pegasus / Firefly Queen

03: (6 creatures, 22nd ~ 27th)
Virus / Skeleton / Graviton Mercenary / Shrieker /
Iridium Warden / Spark

02: (16 creatures, 28th ~ 43rd, median)
Flesh Spider / Hematite Golem / Crimson Dragon / Red Nymph /
Toadfish / Mind Flayer / Nymph Queen / Firefly /
Fate Egg / Anubis / Pharaoh / Ghost of the Past /
Golden Nymph / Parasite / Minor Vampire / Black Nymph

01: (25 creatures, 44th ~ 68th)
Abomination / Purple Dragon / Vulture / Mummy /
Deathstalker / Grey Nymph / Armagio / Colossal Dragon /
Chimera / Antlion / Stone Dragon / Auburn Nymph /
Forest Scorpion / Chrysaora / Blue Crawler / Golden Dragon /
Guardian Angel / Light Nymph / Dragonfly / Deja Vu /
Black Dragon / Gargoyle / Immortal / Turquoise Nymph /
Voodoo Doll

00: (16 creatures, 69th ~ 84th)
Lycanthrope / Schrödinger's Cat / Bone Dragon / Graviton Fire Eater /
Gnome Rider / Emerald Dragon / Rustler / Cockatrice /
Ash Eater / Fire Spirit / Ice Dragon / Wyrm /
Azure Dragon / Devonian Dragon / Scarab / Phase Spider

I enjoyed making this.

Thanks, I meant to compile that eventually.

[BC]

Good to see that Fallen Elf at least made the top 10.

[Boingo]

I call shenanigans on this poll so far--turquoise nymph has only received 3 votes so far?!?!?  Has nobody heard about its buff to 4 hp? 

[Captain Scibra]

Did all , for I think it has some of the best control and special abilities.  In order from most uber to least:

• Oty - Most powerful CC card in the game, good target for the new Acceleration when it gets big
• Amber nymph - Awesome QC, and nice healing source against rainbows
• Sapphire Charger - Good cost for damage and momentum
• Armagio -  Great target for Acceleration
• Graviton Mercenary - Cheap fodder, and decent target for Acceleration but needs healing support

[Alzaya-God Of Thunder]

As if only one other person voted for Goldy Dragy!

[xn0ize]

purple nymph
otyugh
phoenix
lava destroyer
crusader

i think this is the Legit list, all should vote this

[jmdt]

purple nymph
otyugh
phoenix
lava destroyer
crusader

i think this is the Legit list, all should vote this

I can buy the other cards, but crusader is not legit.

[killybob]

why not? if you amass 6 crusaders with rewind or destroy you do large portions of damage and huge CC/PC

[FinalFrontier]

crusaders are mainly an alternative to flying wepons

[xn0ize]

Not alternative, you see. you can use 12 weapons, 6 crusader, 6 AM and weapons.