-Is this project a good idea in and of itself
-What direction(s) should it take
-What content / suggestions should be added
-What should get removed.
-It was. Okay, thats kinda my bad for not being more specific: when / where did it go wrong.
-It should stop now.
-For now, nothing.
-A lot of stuff. Such as?...
^This was meant as a starting point for a poll or set of polls to get some feedback from the EtG community as a whole.
This debate has been going for less than a week and its already getting so long that its hard to track down what has been said...
In the interest of a sanity check, can we get a thread or something with all the relevant points placed at the top. (otherwise the mindflayers are going to have to come in and perform a mass '
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6bce6/6bce6416d1b3994142b209e6e368a63cf9be6a3c" alt="Aether :aether"
: lobotomy ' to prevent people from trying to use their '
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/25d82/25d826a75dabb18288f7c4f300de18543cec2ceb" alt="Air :air"
: snipe ' skill on each other ... don't make me break out the card image quotes and memes... I'll do it!)
A poll / polls would also be good so we can get a concrete measure of the community's standing as a whole.
I would start the thread myself but as I have been helping with the project, it would be better to get a neutral unbiased member to post and moderate. (I'm not sure if that's possible at this point but at least lets find someone without a potential conflict of interest)
I realize that members on both sides have strong opinions, but lets try to keep things civil, and rational so we can get a (hopefully democratic) resolution process going instead of continuing this long drawn out flame war further.