I'll pick one for each element
: Nova. It just fits in so many decks, and makes a number of decks possible that wouldn't otherwise be. (discord is a very strong runner up)
: Bone wall. It's really strong, and combos well with creature removal, which is generally something you're using in pvp anyway
: Probably shard of focus, when shards are allowed. Gravity is generally pretty poor in pvp. Shardless, I thnk I'd go with sapphire chargers.
: This is a tough one; there are many strong cards for pvp in earth. I think I'll go with earthquake, though; it's strong enough in pvp that it gets banned a lot, and an early earthquake can just wreck someone.
: Shard of gratitude (for sharded events), and probably horned frog otherwise, just because they're so fast, particularly with fractal.
: Fire's a tough one to pick; fire is a very good pvp element. I think I'll go with phoenix on this one, though; it's so hard to remove, and hits really hard. Honourable mentions to firebolt and immolation, though.
: Shard of patience for sharded events; the raw power of this card is just insane. Shardless, I'd pick arctic squid. If the opponent cannot remove it, a squid can just dominate the entire game.
: Miracle. Oh, you left me at 3hp? That's fine, I'm at 99 again. Have fun!
: This one's pretty tough, but I'll go with blue nymph. It's extremely strong, and I've seen tourney rulesets where blue nymph completely dominates, enough that it probably gets more bans than any other nymph in pvp events. (honourable mention to owl's eye for nymphless events, because it can control a board almost by itself)
: Pretty tough call here, but I think I'll go with eternity. An eternity on the other side of the board completely changes how you play; no longer can you just play one creature a turn, or you'll never draw anything else again. (honourable mention to hourglass)
: Tough one here, but I'll go with devourer. It's a card that often has to be accounted for in pvp events.
: Hmm... I have to pick one of the two big elephants in the room. I think I'd go with dimensional shield, though. If the opponent has no way to deal with chained shields, they might as well just go home. Honourable mention is, of course, fractal.