MasterWalks Card Tier List- Weapons

[InsignificantWeeaboo]

Vagger does wreck entire archetypes. It is a 12 hp swing for 2 quanta ffs

Keep in mind that the unupped weapon is being used. 8 HP swing, which is a little less of a significant swing.

[CactusKing]

Vagger does wreck entire archetypes. It is a 12 hp swing for 2 quanta ffs

Which archetypes may I ask? I think you overestimate vagger. It's best use is dark domins, and the best dark domin (ghostmare) doesn't even use it.

[ddevans96]

If Ghost and Nightmare were introduced today, there's no way a typical Ghostmare wouldn't run VD. The fact that it doesn't is a product of a different era - unless you're specifically predicting a deck Eternity is strong against, or in a primarily unupped meta, there's very little reason not to use it in Ghostmare right now.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

If it is just un-upped then fine, I was thinking of the most commonly used upgrade level of the weapons

I'm enjoying being told I'm overestimating cards.

The 3 most experienced and decorated PVP players in this thread all consider Vagger S tier, but If it is only unupped then fine.

[Wyand]

Talking about unupped it is only 8, but can still hurt a lot. As I like to say Darkness has the best 2-card stall option: Stiletto/Dagger+Dusk.

EDIT: Ooops, haven't noticed the last 4 posts...

[MasterWalks]

If it is just un-upped then fine, I was thinking of the most commonly used upgrade level of the weapons

I'm enjoying being told I'm overestimating cards.

The 3 most experienced and decorated PVP players in this thread all consider Vagger S tier, but If it is only unupped then fine.

It is un-upped and only un-upped. The beginning of the thread underlines this.

The 3 most experienced and decorated PVP players in this thread all consider Vagger S tier, but If it is only unupped then fine.

When reading the reply's, PvP experience is something i consider greatly. But as many experienced PvP players have said in both here and blab, its S Tier when Upped. Un-Upped its a Strong A Tier

[shockcannon]

Upped rankings:

Vagger
Discord
Arsenic
Jade Staff
Eagle's Eye
Titan
Eternity
Poseidon
Pulverizer
Fahrenheit
Electrocutor
Long Sword
Morning Glory
Gavel
Longbow
Dirk

[MasterWalks]

Upped rankings:

Vagger
Discord
Arsenic
Jade Staff
Eagle's Eye
Titan
Eternity
Poseidon
Pulverizer
Fahrenheit
Electrocutor
Long Sword
Morning Glory
Gavel
Longbow
Dirk

Yea thats going to be a no from me man.

Vagger
Discord
Eternity
Arsenic
Titan
Morning Glory
Poseidon
Eagles Eye
Pulverizer
Long Sword
Fahrenheit
Jade Staff
Electrocutor
Gavel
Longbow
Dirk

[immortal feud]

yeah how you gonna put upped druidic staff as 3rd best

[ARTHANASIOS]

yeah how you gonna put upped druidic staff as 3rd best

Tbh, Druidic/Jade Stuff without Animate Weapon & Adrenaline is both underrated & underused a lot. But, if you think about it, it is the most similar weapon to Vagger. Yeah, Vagger does more damage/healing but only if your opponent does not use a DR shield. There are enough shield-related situations where Jade Stuff is FAR better than Vagger...

[dawn to dusk]

Sure it's good, I don't think anyone is going to argue that it's usable, and has varying uses in any life deck that doesn't have a better slot (especially mono), but comparing it to the likes of Eagles Eye, and a few others, it seems a bit underwhelming.
I personally wouldn't rate Titan as high, sure CataTitans is a thing but I find Electrocutor to be a fair bit higher than rated currently