Guilds: Become part of the journey!

[Laxadarap]

Your answer in regards to being awarded GP through crucible.  This is a pretty straightforward and fantastic idea, but how large will guilds be.  As in, a guild could spamvote a members cards through the crucible in order to win the GP, not based on card ideas.  I'm not saying anybody would be crooked, but if somebody posted a thread saying "hey, vote this", a lot of people probably would.

[TribalTrouble]

Wait so, would it be possible for any small group of members to just keep the GP to themselves to spend on their own ETG accounts? (Referencing the 1k electrum idea)

[ARTHANASIOS]

One thing is sure. If Guilds have Brawl related tasks, then I hope I will bring Guild of to the very top! 8)

[artimies7]

Thank you Hyro, those answers were not really vague sometimes.

Now I must declare two different scenarios.

A) One recieves GP from getting cards into the CI&A Smithy process.
B) When a member of a guild gets GP, the guild to which he belongs increases in some tangible way.

I must say that after some thought, I don't believe that these scenarios can coexist, for reasons of:

I'm not saying anybody would be crooked, but if somebody posted a thread saying "hey, vote this", a lot of people probably would.

There's always n00bs on the internet. Few filter into this sometimes not so serious community, but they still exist and there is a risk.

Scenario A is especially problematic on principle alone, so I recommend forgoing most amounts of GP awards for directly submitting card ideas and creating scenario B to a greater extent.

Expand at your own will.

[Chapuz]

One thing is sure. If Guilds have Brawl related tasks, then I hope I will bring Guild of to the very top! 8)

Brawl will start before guilds are set, so for Brawl #2 there will be a system where the players will get GPs for their future guilds by winning their tasks. The Guildmasters will detail this system when they see it's time.

[Hyroen]

Spoiler for Wouldn't there be a possibility for voting corruption in Guilds through the Smithy system?:

Your answer in regards to being awarded GP through crucible.  This is a pretty straightforward and fantastic idea, but how large will guilds be.  As in, a guild could spamvote a members cards through the crucible in order to win the GP, not based on card ideas.  I'm not saying anybody would be crooked, but if somebody posted a thread saying "hey, vote this", a lot of people probably would.

It's a valid point. I would hope that the community is honourable, but this concern is currently in our discussion.

Spoiler for Can any small group of member just keep the GP and spend them on their own EtG accounts?:

Wait so, would it be possible for any small group of members to just keep the GP to themselves to spend on their own ETG accounts? (Referencing the 1k electrum idea)

If you are referring to the fact that as Guilds have a few amount of people in power, that they could use the GP all by themselves, yes it's possible. But I doubt anyone would want to be in that Guild.