Re: Round 6 - GP - Voting Phase https://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php?topic=61772.msg1230931#msg1230931
« Reply #1 on: April 17, 2016, 05:12:20 am »
TNT: Toadally Newtral Team
AB: Abyss Brawlers
LoS: League of Shadows
FHM: Fiery-Hot Mixtape
TC: The Chaosomes
Gaia's Pride: Gaia's Pride
|
Boss & CD | Gaia's Pride | AB -- They had pictures on the cards, followed the part of the task that was explicit and clear, and had good card with good stall in the constructed deck. Only team that did that besides GP. | Artist & DB | Gaia's Pride | AB -- Fractal Skeletons? This touches a place in my EtG heart, being twice Master of Death. The video/art was sublime too. | FE | LoS -- the most thorough of the submission, by far! | TC -- Did not start their submission with an insult (even a light-hearted cheeky one...) and went in depth enough to get my 2nd vote. | Writer | Gaia's Pride | AB -- a novel is not good for intro that has to play/scroll/etc EVERY time a player loads the game, but this one was shorter and good. Thumbs up! | Bonus | Gaia's Pride | AB -- More AB here... this time the "Blue Submarine" slayed me, classic and very well thought up. Tough to top. | Super Bonus | AB -- Another solid krzy art-ed comic with good JCJ script and such, bravo! | TC -- I enjoyed the playful back-and-forth and overview of Brawl to-date... with humor injected quite skillfully. | Challenge | refer below | ditto |
|
Espithel's Frustration | AB -- The more "real" of the two cards... which the task seemed explicitly to be taking aim at some kind of "reality" in the card being created. |
Espithel's Delirium | FHM -- I love the simple complexity and depth here... one level deep that gets the task completed, and I like the addition of a human-esque element to the game. Maybe not ACTUALLY in the game, but in something like Brawl it draws my vote. |
Espithel's Duplicity | FHM -- They chose my team and gave a shout-out compliment to me on my card's portion of it. <3 Thanks FHM - it does indeed properly deserve a vote from me for those reasons. |
Ulamog, the Ceaseless NearHundred | AB -- Very fitting for the chosen element, Gravity, and it is the more straight forward of the two cards. I'm not sure I really understand the FHM card or it's accompanying explanations. |
Elite Dragonfly the Science Guy | TC or AB -- AB forfeited it seems... |
Animated Tribute | Gaia's Pride -- Simple and animated, not too complex and includes the whole team. |
Mechanical Underdrive | AB -- This is cool, making a nice card that uses oppposite elements in one card with a new mechanic. |
Ascension | LoS -- A more thorough submission with a better deck that appeals to my DB fancy. |
Buy one get one free! | LoS -- This was actually a real attempt to create an advertisement. |
« Last Edit: April 17, 2016, 05:14:17 am by rob77dp »
Logged
Death War #12/TBD TTG Brawl #6/1st Death War #10/9th GP Brawl #5/6th Death War #9/9th MoL Brawl #4/3rd Water War #8/7th DDD Brawl #3/3rd*Death War #7/5th*Death War #6/11th