The Witch's Game 3

[Fippe94]

Very good. But allow me to cut them all down with only a single red truth:
Howard never entered the room where Charlie was hiding.

[Torriku]

Very good. But allow me to cut them all down with only a single red truth:
Howard never entered the room where Charlie was hiding.

Howard used a Throwing Knife

[Fippe94]

Ah, but then you forget that when Charlie was killed, the murderer was in the same room as him.

[Torriku]

Howard stabbed Charlie then tossed in the room as if he were hiding.

[Submachine]

When Charlie opened the door for Howard, Lucy was waiting for the opportunity. She busted in the door and abused the fact that everyone was surprised, quickly stabbed Charlie to his death then using Howard's fear, she shouted at Howard and forced him to go in his room and hang himself.

In my second blue truth, I never said that Howard stepped into the room. So counter that one too, please!

So what I know currently:
Charlie opened the door for Howard. But when the door opened, Howard stayed outside and Lucy was the one who entered and killed Charlie. When Lucy left, Howard locked the door with the masterkey.

[Fippe94]

Not bad, not bad at all...

Howard stabbed Charlie then tossed in the room as if he were hiding.

When Charlie opened the door for Howard, Lucy was waiting for the opportunity. She busted in the door and abused the fact that everyone was surprised, quickly stabbed Charlie to his death then using Howard's fear, she shouted at Howard and forced him to go in his room and hang himself.

In my second blue truth, I never said that Howard stepped into the room. So counter that one too, please!

So what I know currently:
Charlie opened the door for Howard. But when the door opened, Howard stayed outside and Lucy was the one who entered and killed Charlie. When Lucy left, Howard locked the door with the masterkey.

I bring you this truth:
When Charlie died, Howard was already dead.

[Torriku]

Howard opened the door after Lucy threatened to stab him, she then killed him and then stabbed Charlie then tossed Charlie into the room as if he were hiding. And hung Howard downstairs.

[Fippe94]

Howard died from hanging.

[Torriku]

Howard opened the door then Lucy took him downstairs him, she then took Howard down, got him to hang himself. Went back to the room charlie was hiding in, kill charlie then went out the room.

[Fippe94]

If Charlie knew that he was in danger, he would lock his door as soon as he could.

[Torriku]

Howard opened the door then Lucy took him downstairs him, she then took Howard down, got him to hang himself. Went back to the room charlie was hiding in, kill charlie then went out the room.

If that doesn't work, Lucy took Howard down and threatened to hang him, then took the master key, went upstairs and unlocked the room Charile was hiding in, then proceed to stab charlie.

[Fippe94]

Charlie would not leave the door open and unlocked if he knew there was a murderer in the building.

As for the second, I already posted: Lucy never used the master key to unlock a door.