The thing is, Heaven is associated with Light. Light is only one of the 12 elements, thus it has no rights to "judge" beings affiliated with the other elements. If this is only the view of your Angels and not yourself, then I, as Jonathan Haemos Shade, and as Bloodshadow the Master of Darkness, will personally make sure that they understand their place in the power echelon. Perhaps Jonathan could have an epic battle with your most xenophobic Angels (excluding Catyrael, of course, since we deliberately avoid direct conflict between players), in which he reveals his second dragon form (first dragon form is 50% full Master power, second is 62.5%); it seems to me that somebody needs to teach those Angels a lesson.
Oh, yes! Xanriel could be captured by Heaven to be judged, and all of us can go there to rescue him. All right then, this can be another arc in our storyline.
However, I still feel very uneasy about Light and Darkness being the only elements with their respective higher realms. Elemental equality should be valued above all things, since it is essential in Elements the Game itself.
Double post.
Bloodshadow, you are quite welcome to duel with Emparael when he descends to the Lower World when he apprehends Xanriel and to prove the wrongness of such a xenophobic attitude and also perhaps the notion of Heaven's continued "major interventions" having truly become something of the past now that its power is but a shadow of its fomer glorious self.
However, I must object to your second point on the grounds of "fighting one, if not more Greater Archangels
in Heaven being an extremely
bad idea, even for an Elemental Master. It would be much wiser to allow the Council to reach its verdict, as opposed to declaring outright war on the spiritual realm which is as eternal as many gods. Further, once you factor and take into account, their inherent power, the decisive "home turf" advantage and their respective eternities of knowledge and experience, I would not be inclined to believe that it is a war you can ultimately win, even as an Elemental Master.
Finally, I would even propose that having been conferred something ressembling divine powers, gifts and the accompanying responsibilities (recall the Mantle, to which I made reference during the Council discussion? It indicates their duty to guard and to act in the best interest of those from the Lower World), they do hold the right, to a certain extent, to judge the Lower World, but only to a limited degree. Excessive interference is uncalled for, which is why, for instance, I would perceive Emparael to be in the moral wrong when he storms earth with an Army unit to "arrest" Xanriel.
I think Catyrael and Xanriel should be "old friends". We need to have something like the good cop and bad cop when Xanriel was judged.
I request a fight against Emparael, if he is the most xenophobic of all your Angels. Also, what do you think about the party going to Heaven to rescue Xanriel? During that arc, Sirenes could also have her half-Angelic powers awakened.
Regarding your newest post, Blood, I actually do favour the "old friends" concept myself, for its potential. As I stated, your request for a fight against Emparael is gladly granted, on the condition that it is
on earth. While I would be fine with the party
visiting Heaven and acting as non-violent participants in the trial, as stated above, I do not believe you could march in their pugnaciously.
Concerning Sirenes, I am sure the wiser among the Greater Archangels would be of invaluable assistance in awakening her half-Angelic powers; she hardly needs to fight them.
I don't think he'll need to be saved. I think it could be dealt with between the angels. I think in the end, Xanriel can't really be blamed, and that Catyrael won't let anything bad happen to him.
As for their relationship, why not both? Old friends, but Catyrael has always been better at angel duties, and has always been Xanriel's superior, so while they get along like old friends, there is still the knowledge that Catyrael is the indisputable superior. Like one of those situations where you expect your friend to go easy on you because your friends, but you respect them more because they don't give special consideration to anyone.
Also, if Jonathan wants to fight the angels of heaven over this dispute, then I'm pretty sure Xanriel would personally step in as a Proxy on heaven's behalf.
Xanriel started off as being affiliated with Life, then became stronger in the light aspect. I think that we should split the elements into three groups. Three heavenly, Three Hell, Three Middle.
I'd say
for the heavenly council
for the Middle council, and
for the Hell
Each has their own designs for the world, and while they are not enemies, and none of them are evil, they are also not always allies, and generally don't agree.
So in this case, even though Death and Darkness are part of the same council, death and darkness are clearly in disagreement with eachother, in which the Light aspect of heaven has decided to step in and try to keep the middle ground safe.
I think we're getting hung up on heaven and hell as opposites. This isn't real life, we can make them whatever we want people.
In summary, I concur with essentially everything stated above.
Regarding the lack of a need to actually "save" Xanriel, I am in complete agreement. After all, he is among his own kin and people, and as Archangel of Justice, Catyrael will not permit Xanriel to suffer any ill fate.
Concerning the Catyrael-Xanriel relationship, I like your idea about incorporating both elements. Unofficially, they are close friends, but there is also an official hierarchy to be observed and respected.
Finally, of all the proposed ideas which seek to firmly establish Elemental equilibrium, I am most partial towards this one as now, all 12 Elements have a seat on a council, while Light's heavenly status is preserved.
Note: My responses are relevant only to the post in question; as soon as I had finished with the first, a second following post was up, and this repeated itself for the third.
The content of those responses was appropriate for the time when the original post was put up and have not been revised yet; if it contradicts the present situation, assume the latter to be the truth.