You might have convinced me but you just seemed to be overdoing it. Subtle confusion is better than OMG WTF! :-p
Well since the game was ruined, I'll go ahead and reveal: I'm the seer. I'm also the immortal. I used my seer ability on Essence, who is a gambler. Essence then used his gambler ability on me and Terro. We were hoping that either I'd find out who Terro was and could add him to our group/find out he was an FG or if he found out who I was, that he wasn't an FG. So ya, we gambled and it payed off.