Elements Mafia 77 - by Linkcat

[Pokechu]

I'm beginning to suspect a mafia member among kae/kdz/poke, but I think all theoretical teams at this point have to include either w3 or Oa. Any chance we can shoot them both? Ideally, the team is w3/Oa/MW and we can just lynch them all sequentially, but I don't expect things to go that smoothly.

If I'm not mistaken, valid targets for FTW tonight are Poke, Oa, kdz, and rob. Oa isn't going to shoot himself regardless of alignment, and of those, only Poke feels like a reasonable target. Thoughts?

What happened here?

[MasterWalks]

lol

I don't think poke is the way to go. See, kdz is like the only one who townread Oa. Oa has been scum read all game by like everyone. So I would like to see Oa hit kdz. If KDZ flips red then we know kdz was protecting a scum!Oa. The thing is, if Oa is scum, then Vigging a teammate is probably a strange strategy. If KDZ flips green then we kill poke.

[skyironsword]

I'm beginning to suspect a mafia member among kae/kdz/poke, but I think all theoretical teams at this point have to include either w3 or Oa. Any chance we can shoot them both? Ideally, the team is w3/Oa/MW and we can just lynch them all sequentially, but I don't expect things to go that smoothly.

If I'm not mistaken, valid targets for FTW tonight are Poke, Oa, kdz, and rob. Oa isn't going to shoot himself regardless of alignment, and of those, only Poke feels like a reasonable target. Thoughts?

What happened here?

Absolutely nothing. Just because there might be a mafia member in that group of people, doesn't mean I have to suspect them all equally.

[Pokechu]

I'm beginning to suspect a mafia member among kae/kdz/poke, but I think all theoretical teams at this point have to include either w3 or Oa. Any chance we can shoot them both? Ideally, the team is w3/Oa/MW and we can just lynch them all sequentially, but I don't expect things to go that smoothly.

If I'm not mistaken, valid targets for FTW tonight are Poke, Oa, kdz, and rob. Oa isn't going to shoot himself regardless of alignment, and of those, only Poke feels like a reasonable target. Thoughts?

What happened here?

Absolutely nothing. Just because there might be a mafia member in that group of people, doesn't mean I have to suspect them all equally.

I never implied that though.

[skyironsword]

Then what are you implying? I'm afraid I don't follow.

[Pokechu]

Then what are you implying? I'm afraid I don't follow.

LOL I'm sorry for the crypticness I won't do that anymore

You said you suspected KDZ in the first quote and he's also in the bottom 4 posters, yet you said I was the only reasonable choice of the 4. But you also suspect KDZ? So it's a bit disingenuous to say I'm the only "reasonable" choice when there's KDZ + you could also be asking me questions. Not to say that I should be given a safety rope, since I shouldn't necessarily; but it would help make your posts seem more genuine instead of going "yeah he's the only reasonable choice. BUT I won't ask him anything to try to either change my mind/cement my opinion"

LOL

[skyironsword]

LOL I'm sorry for the crypticness I won't do that anymore

You said you suspected KDZ in the first quote and he's also in the bottom 4 posters, yet you said I was the only reasonable choice of the 4. But you also suspect KDZ? So it's a bit disingenuous to say I'm the only "reasonable" choice when there's KDZ + you could also be asking me questions. Not to say that I should be given a safety rope, since I shouldn't necessarily; but it would help make your posts seem more genuine instead of going "yeah he's the only reasonable choice. BUT I won't ask him anything to try to either change my mind/cement my opinion"

LOL

I suspect you much more than I suspect KDZ. I think that's a reasonable stance, given the circumstances. Sure, I could ask you questions, but I'm also not obligated to.

[Pokechu]

LOL I'm sorry for the crypticness I won't do that anymore

You said you suspected KDZ in the first quote and he's also in the bottom 4 posters, yet you said I was the only reasonable choice of the 4. But you also suspect KDZ? So it's a bit disingenuous to say I'm the only "reasonable" choice when there's KDZ + you could also be asking me questions. Not to say that I should be given a safety rope, since I shouldn't necessarily; but it would help make your posts seem more genuine instead of going "yeah he's the only reasonable choice. BUT I won't ask him anything to try to either change my mind/cement my opinion"

LOL

I suspect you much more than I suspect KDZ. I think that's a reasonable stance, given the circumstances. Sure, I could ask you questions, but I'm also not obligated to.

you're not obligated but it's not a good look if you're not willing to engage with those you suspect. also tbf I wouldn't say KDZ has done much more than I have, I feel like this game is basically the Serp show feat. Torb + Rob

[MasterWalks]

LOL I'm sorry for the crypticness I won't do that anymore

You said you suspected KDZ in the first quote and he's also in the bottom 4 posters, yet you said I was the only reasonable choice of the 4. But you also suspect KDZ? So it's a bit disingenuous to say I'm the only "reasonable" choice when there's KDZ + you could also be asking me questions. Not to say that I should be given a safety rope, since I shouldn't necessarily; but it would help make your posts seem more genuine instead of going "yeah he's the only reasonable choice. BUT I won't ask him anything to try to either change my mind/cement my opinion"

LOL

I suspect you much more than I suspect KDZ. I think that's a reasonable stance, given the circumstances. Sure, I could ask you questions, but I'm also not obligated to.

you're not obligated but it's not a good look if you're not willing to engage with those you suspect. also tbf I wouldn't say KDZ has done much more than I have, I feel like this game is basically the Serp show feat. Torb + Rob+ MasterNoob

Ftfy

[skyironsword]

"Not willing to engage" is a stretch, considering I just happened to not be talking to you at the time.

[Pokechu]

"Not willing to engage" is a stretch, considering I just happened to not be talking to you at the time.

I never said you had to start asking me questions now, I meant it generally. Just as you meant that you aren't obligated to ask me questions, generally (assuming you would ask me an important question if the situation called for it)

[rob77dp]

Important question - are you Anti?